The fight over Governor Gavin Newsom's decision to commute every death sentence in California moved from the podium to the courtroom on Monday, when victims' families, district attorneys and law-enforcement groups filed an original writ petition in the California Supreme Court asking the justices to void all 548 commutations and to halt them immediately. The petition, Friend v. Newsom, is the first actual court filing against the mass clemency since Newsom announced it on November 5 — four days after the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation announced at a Sacramento press conference on November 12 that it would challenge the plan, a step Awaaz Punjab reported at the time.
Source: CalMatters, via Lost Coast Outpost
According to the At the Lectern legal journal's summary of the filing, the petitioners are 31 murder victims' family members, 28 county district attorneys and various organisations, and the case is led by Sandy Friend, whose eight-year-old son Michael Lyons was murdered. CalMatters reported that the district attorneys of 30 counties argued in the lawsuit, filed Monday morning, that the state's high court should halt the commutations. The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, which advocates for crime victims, filed the case on behalf of district attorneys, law-enforcement leaders and victims and their families, KVCR Public Media reported.
Source: Horvitz & Levy — At the Lectern
What the petition argues
The lawsuit asserts that Newsom acted unlawfully when he proposed commuting the sentences of 548 prisoners by failing to afford the victims of their crimes the “opportunity to be heard,” CalMatters reported. “Only this court can stop the governor's disregard of the law — his abuse of power,” the petitioners wrote to the California Supreme Court. The petition argues that a governor's clemency power in California is not unlimited the way a president's pardon power is: when condemned prisoners apply for a commutation, governors must notify the district attorney in the county where the crime took place, and the victims or their families.
The legal hook is the state constitution and the Penal Code. California's constitution makes the governor's clemency powers “[s]ubject to application procedures provided by statute,” and Penal Code section 4802 requires commutation applications from twice-convicted felons — the cases the Supreme Court must approve — to be made directly to the governor through that statutory process. If the petition succeeds, it would prevent Newsom from issuing any death-sentence commutations at all, not only the roughly 400 for which the constitution requires Supreme Court permission, At the Lectern noted. The petition also asks the court to immediately stay any commutation grants while the case is decided.
Source: Horvitz & Levy — At the Lectern
The governor's answer, filed in advance
Newsom anticipated the argument. In an explanatory statement issued with the commutations, he wrote that the Penal Code section highlighted by the district attorneys “does not apply when the governor acts on his own initiative to grant clemency absent an application” — because none of the 548 proposed commutations stemmed from an application by a prisoner on death row, he argues, the statutory notification requirements were never triggered. He added that after he submitted the proposed commutations to the Supreme Court, his office would notify the district attorneys in the counties where the crimes were committed and seek their help with notifications, CalMatters reported.
In a response to KVCR, a spokesperson for the governor's office quoted Newsom's announcement letter for the mass commutations. “I deeply respect the views of those who will strongly disagree with my decision,” Newsom wrote. “Including some families of victims who have suffered the worst possible loss.” In the same letter he wrote that California society is made stronger by rejecting “state-sanctioned killing.”
Source: KVCR Public Media
The families and prosecutors behind the case
The foundation's chief executive, Anne Marie Schubert, a former Sacramento County district attorney, said the group is challenging all of the governor's commutations, alleging he failed to follow California law and abused his executive power. “Together, we are asking the court to uphold the law, respect the sanctity of jury verdicts and protect the rights of victims,” Schubert said. Members of the District Attorneys Association said California law requires district attorneys to be notified by the governor in the commutation process.
Source: KVCR Public Media
At the Capitol press conference organised by the foundation, Mary Muscarella, whose son Paul Bailey was murdered in 1990, was one of a dozen victims' family members who spoke. “California voters have twice voted to retain the death penalty,” Muscarella said. “Is it about justice or is it about positioning oneself for a larger political future?” The foundation says the sweeping action overrides repeated decisions by voters and undermines the verdicts of juries and the judgments of courts — the same arguments prosecutors in Los Angeles and Orange counties made when they backed the announced challenge last week.
The other side of the argument
Supporters of the commutations answer that the death penalty itself has failed the families it claims to serve. Kate Chatfield, executive director of the California Public Defenders Association, told KVCR that the death penalty has not served murder victims' families in some 20 years — California has not executed anyone since 2006 — and added: “And I will say that [...] not all families [of victims] believe in the death penalty. They're not a monolithic group.” Amicus briefs from the California Appellate Project, the Habeas Corpus Resource Center and the State Public Defender, filed earlier this month in the court's commutation-review docket, urge the justices to approve the governor's request promptly and argue the court's role is limited to checking for an abuse of discretion.
What is solid
- An original writ petition, Friend v. Newsom, was filed in the California Supreme Court on Monday morning, Nov 16, asking the court to void all 548 commutations and stay them immediately
- Petitioners include murder victims' family members, county district attorneys and organisations, represented through the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation
- The petition's core claim is procedural: Newsom failed to give victims an opportunity to be heard and skipped statutory notifications to district attorneys and victims' families
- Newsom's stated position is that the notification statutes do not apply because he acted on his own initiative, with no prisoner application
What is only claimed
- Whether a blanket, governor-initiated commutation must follow the application procedures of Penal Code section 4802 — the petitioners say yes, the governor says no; the Supreme Court has not ruled
- How many district attorneys stand behind the filing: CalMatters describes the DAs of 30 counties arguing in the suit, while At the Lectern's petitioner count lists 28 county district attorneys
Background: from moratorium to mass commutation
Newsom issued a moratorium on executions in 2019 and later ordered the dismantling of the death chamber at San Quentin State Prison. On November 5, weeks before leaving office, he announced he would commute all 548 California death sentences to life in prison without the possibility of parole — in a state that holds the largest death row in the United States. His successor, Governor-elect Xavier Becerra, has committed to extending the execution moratorium when he takes office. The Supreme Court will get a say on almost 400 of the commutations in any event, because state law requires the court to review cases in which the prisoner was convicted of multiple felonies; representatives of the court have not said how or when those reviews would take place.
What happens next
The immediate question is the stay: if the justices grant the petitioners' request, no commutation can take effect while Friend v. Newsom is argued. The court must also run its separate, case-by-case review of the roughly 400 multiple-felony commutations already before it. For the 548 condemned prisoners, the victims' families on both sides of the argument, and the prosecutors who won the original verdicts, Monday's filing means the largest mass clemency in California history will now be decided not by the governor's signature alone, but by the state's highest court.
