SAN DIEGO, California — San Diego's City Council voted unanimously on Monday evening, November 16, to end the city's contract with Flock Safety and stop the operation of its automated license plate reader (ALPR) cameras across the city, in one of the largest municipal rejections of the surveillance technology in the United States. The vote is the final full-council decision that the council's Budget and Government Efficiency Committee left open on October 21, when the committee voted to rescind approval for the readers and end the contract — a step Awaaz Punjab reported at the time. In the same meeting, the council voted 5-2 to rescind the authorization for Ubicquia's smart streetlights, the camera-equipped streetlight system that worked alongside the plate readers.

Source: NBC 7 San Diego, Nov 16-17, 2026

The decision the committee left open

On October 21, San Diego's Budget and Government Efficiency Committee voted to rescind approval for the Flock readers and end the contract, but the full council still had to decide. Monday's unanimous vote is that decision. Read the earlier committee-vote story

The Flock decision came through the council's annual review under the city's TRUST ordinance, the law that requires yearly re-authorization of surveillance technologies used by the San Diego Police Department. The council elected to stop authorization for SDPD to use the technology, which has been in effect since 2023. Dozens of other surveillance technologies used by the department had their authorizations continued at the same meeting — the plate readers and the smart streetlights were the ones the council singled out and ended.

The misuse case that flipped the council

Council President Joe LaCava docketed the item for Monday, ahead of its usual December slot, in light of news that the SDPD had used the technology to track one of its own officers and a domestic violence victim with whom the officer was allegedly engaged in an inappropriate relationship, as part of an internal investigation, NBC 7 San Diego reported. That allegation — that a system sold as a crime-fighting tool was turned on a victim and an officer inside the department — became the turning point of the debate.

Support on the council collapsed in stages. Councilmember Stephen Whitburn withdrew his support in October, saying at a press conference that he wanted his fellow citizens to feel safe. After the misuse reports, Councilmembers Raul Campillo and Marni von Wilpert also withdrew their support. All three had voted for using the technology during the 2025 review. Their reversal secured a veto-proof majority, and Monday's final vote was unanimous.

Why one councillor changed his mind

"If Flock cameras are causing many San Diegans to feel unsafe, then they have lost effectiveness as a public safety tool." — Councilmember Stephen Whitburn, October 2026

Mayor Todd Gloria, who had urged the council to approve the program three years ago, said in a social media post after the vote that he respected the council's decision and would not veto the move to stop operation of the cameras across the city. The reversal is a remarkable turnabout from 2023, when the mayor and other municipal leaders championed the system.

The police case for the cameras — and Flock's response

Police representatives told Monday's meeting that vehicle theft in San Diego has fallen 20 percent since 2023, and that 689 stolen vehicles had been recovered as a result of the Flock cameras. Supporters of the technology argue those numbers show the cameras solve real crimes, and that removing them will be felt first by victims waiting for their cases to be solved.

Flock spokesperson Andrew Smith told Ars Technica in an email on Tuesday that the company also respects the city's decision, but warned that "when a tool that is actively helping solve violent crimes is removed, public safety moves backward." Smith said cases will take longer to solve, organized retail theft crews will operate with fewer obstacles, a missing child may not be returned home, and victims may wait longer, or indefinitely, for justice. Flock is a startup with an estimated valuation of $8.3 billion.

UnanimousCouncil vote to end the Flock authorization
5-2Vote to rescind smart streetlights
689Stolen vehicles police credit to Flock since 2023
20%Fall in vehicle theft police cited since 2023
500Ubicquia cameras in the 2023 installation plan

The streetlights have their own history in San Diego. The city once purchased thousands of smart streetlight systems from a different vendor, GE Current, but a previous mayoral administration shuttered them in 2020. Ubicquia later acquired the smart city platform and proposed a newer installation of 500 cameras in 2023, in partnership with Flock and supported by police, which was installed that year. The city's own Privacy Advisory Board had asked the council to vote the plan down at the time; one of its members, Pegah Parsi, said this week she felt vindication, urging every city and agency that creates an expert advisory board to actually listen to it.

Opponents who had campaigned for years through the Transparent and Responsible Use of Surveillance Technology (TRUST) SD Coalition celebrated the result. Lilly Irani of the coalition, speaking in her personal capacity, credited what she called the national energy creating left, right and centre coalitions against the cameras for the political victory. Oakland-based advocacy group Secure Justice said it has documented at least 513 Flock contracts that have ended, in red and blue states and in large and small cities alike.

San Diego's vote did not happen in isolation. On Tuesday night, the town council of Fountain Hills, Arizona, voted 5-2 to ban license plate readers outright — before any were installed there — and Georgia investigators this week charged former police officers over alleged misuse of Flock searches, cases Awaaz Punjab has covered separately. Together, the decisions show the fight over plate readers moving from privacy blogs into council chambers and courtrooms across the country.

What happens next

With the authorization ended and the mayor declining to veto, the cameras are to stop operating across San Diego and the contracts wound down. The practical questions now are how quickly the network goes dark, what happens to the plate data already collected, and whether other large California cities follow. For drivers — including the Punjabi truckers and families who run Southern California's highways every day — plate readers matter because they log every passing vehicle, not only suspects; who can search that record, and for what, is exactly the question San Diego's council has now answered for its own streets.