An Immigration and Customs Enforcement arrest in San Diego's Oak Park neighbourhood on Friday morning, November 13, has become a public fight over what actually happened on a residential street — because a neighbour's security camera recorded it, and because the Department of Homeland Security has now given an account that the family and the video, as reported by local outlets, dispute. Monica Ortega, 18, says an ICE officer shoved her to the ground twice, pointed a gun at her and at her father's truck, and aimed a Taser at her as officers arrested her father, while her 11-year-old sister watched. DHS says Ortega physically attacked officers and reached for an officer's gun. Both accounts cannot be right, and the video is now at the centre of the dispute.
Source: Daylight San Diego
The arrest began as an ordinary school morning. Ortega told Daylight San Diego that her father called at around 7:30 a.m. on Friday to say he was arriving with his truck to take her younger sister to school, as he did every school day. He had parked up a hill from their home so his daughters would not have to walk. Within seconds of stepping outside, Ortega said, she was facing a gun. “I didn't know who he was until he pointed the gun at me and threatened to kill me,” she recalled of the officer. “I got scared, but it was my dad.” She said the officer never identified himself to her by name or badge number.
Source: Daylight San Diego
What the neighbour's camera shows
In Nest footage from a neighbour, reviewed and described by Daylight San Diego and KPBS, an unmarked black SUV pulls closely behind the father's truck as he comes down the hill. He slows and pulls over; the SUV passes him, then, as he returns to the road, manoeuvres to strike his truck. As Ortega ran out of the family home, she saw the SUV hit the truck. In the footage, the officer from the SUV shoves Ortega forcefully to the ground as he moves past her toward the truck. She gets up and follows him; he pushes her again, this time into the path of the truck, which had not yet fully stopped. The truck knocks her down, and the officer then pulls out his gun, pointing it at both father and daughter.
The officer then switches to a Taser, its charging noise audible in the video as he aims at the 18-year-old. Ortega backs into a neighbour's driveway; the officer grabs her, pulls her to the truck, and another officer forcefully handcuffs her — cuffs she said were very tight and left marks on her wrists. Meanwhile, other officers shocked her father with a Taser before removing him from his truck. He later told the family by phone that the Taser left a bad mark and that he was in a lot of pain. One officer tried to pull and kick loose a piece of the black SUV that had become wedged in the truck, gave up, and left the piece behind — neighbour John Bowerman was later photographed holding it. After officers put the father in one of their vehicles and most drove away, the officers who remained discussed what to do with the still-handcuffed Ortega, then released her.
The younger sister, 11, ran to knock on the neighbours' door during the confrontation. Neighbour Katie Jacks said she opened the door and pulled the girl inside to protect her. “Our home felt like a third world country,” Jacks said. This report does not name the 11-year-old, in line with this site's policy of never identifying minor children.
Injuries, hospital — and a police response the family disputes
An ambulance took Ortega to a hospital for evaluation. She returned home on crutches with a bandaged foot and ankle, scrapes on her hands and leg, and intense back pain; in a later phone interview she described a sprained ankle and said neighbours and her community cleaned her wounds. “I was just crying, I couldn't comprehend what was going on,” she said. She also said a San Diego police officer who took her statement rolled his eyes and walked away mid-sentence. “My heart hurt with everything I just went through, and they leave mid-sentence,” she said. The San Diego Police Department did not respond to Daylight San Diego's request for comment before its report was published.
The other account: what DHS says
The Department of Homeland Security offers a different account, and every claim in it is contested. A DHS spokesperson identified the father as Alan Ortega Meneses — Daylight San Diego, citing immigration court records and the family, names him Erick Ortega Meneses — called him a “criminal illegal alien from Mexico,” and said he was arrested “during a targeted enforcement operation.” DHS stated: “After physically attacking officers and reaching for an officer's gun, she was detained.” Ortega disputes that version, and ABC 10News reported that the video it obtained does not capture those actions. DHS also stated that the father struck a government vehicle with his truck and was “observed reaching under his seat” before officers arrested him, and the agency added that he has a lengthy criminal record — a claim the first local report could not match to cases in San Diego court records. ICE says it is considering prosecution for both father and daughter. ICE reported that the father first entered the country nearly 40 years ago and was later deported; immigration court records cited by Daylight San Diego instead show he received a voluntary departure in 2006. ICE did not respond to Daylight San Diego's request for comment before its November 16 report; the DHS statement was reported afterwards, on November 18.
Source: The Mary Sue, citing DHS, KPBS and ABC 10News
The San Diego Police Department stated that its officers were called to “a two-vehicle collision with possible injuries”; a sergeant and about five officers arrived and stayed close to 30 minutes, and the department said the incident with federal agents occurred before SDPD arrived and federal agents were no longer on scene when its officers got there. Councilmember Sean Elo-Rivera, whose district includes the street, shared the police summary he received and said it contains errors when compared with the video: it says the truck was unoccupied when it struck ICE's SUV, and that the father was attempting to flee, while the footage shows him pulling over at the top of the hill. “Trust is being eroded,” Elo-Rivera said, noting the officers wore vests reading “police.”
The family behind the arrest
According to his younger sister, Ortega Meneses has been in the United States since he was about 5 years old. He is a single father who owns a business and is the sole supporter and provider for his two daughters, Ortega said; streamers from his recent 39th birthday still hung in the home, along with the Hot Wheels collection he built up as a way of coping with stress while Ortega fought childhood cancer — twice. Ortega, in her first semester at San Diego City College studying to become a nurse and already holding a Certified Nursing Assistant licence, said her father invested in her bouquet business and drives her to and from classes. Neighbours Jacks and Bowerman described him as an honest, hardworking man dedicated to his children. “He deserves to be here,” Jacks said.
He is now held at the Otay Mesa Detention Center, with a first hearing scheduled in less than two weeks. The family has started an online fundraiser for legal fees and household bills, and Ortega — determined, she said, to finish the semester — is worried about how she and her sister will pay rent. On Saturday, the day after the arrest, Elo-Rivera met the family and neighbours, offered to connect the daughters with support resources, and promised to raise the incident, particularly the police officer's behaviour, with the San Diego City Council, the mayor and the police chief this week.
Elo-Rivera has asked Mayor Todd Gloria for directives requiring San Diego police to release a public report within three working days each time officers respond to incidents involving federal immigration agents, and to help families locate relatives detained by ICE; mayoral staff committed to both requests at a council meeting, according to reporting on the DHS statement. The father's first detention hearing at Otay Mesa is due in less than two weeks, and ICE says it is considering prosecution of both father and daughter — a decision that has not been announced.
What is solid
- ICE officers arrested Monica Ortega's father in San Diego's Oak Park neighbourhood on Friday morning, November 13, as he arrived to take his younger daughter to school; a neighbour's security video records a confrontation in which Ortega, 18, was shoved, knocked down, handcuffed and later released.
- The father is held at the Otay Mesa Detention Center with a first hearing scheduled in less than two weeks, according to the family and local reporting.
- DHS has given a public account of the arrest that the family disputes; ICE did not comment to Daylight San Diego before its November 16 report.
What is only claimed
- Whether Ortega attacked officers or reached for an officer's gun, as DHS states, or was shoved and threatened without doing so, as she and the reported video account say — ABC 10News reported its video does not capture the DHS version.
- The father's record and history: DHS claims a lengthy criminal record and a past deportation; local reporting found no matching San Diego court cases and cites immigration court records showing a 2006 voluntary departure. Even his first name is reported differently — Erick in local reporting and court records, Alan in the DHS statement.
