The United States Supreme Court on Monday, November 16, 2026, declined to hear a First Amendment challenge to California's requirement that continuing medical education courses for doctors include curriculum on implicit bias, leaving the state mandate fully in effect. The justices denied the petition for a writ of certiorari in Khatibi v. Yip, No. 25-1240, in an entry on the Court's Monday order list, with no explanation from the majority.

Source: Supreme Court order list, November 16, 2026

The denial drew a written dissent from Justice Clarence Thomas, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, who argued the Court should have taken the case. Justice Neil Gorsuch also noted that he would have granted the petition. Four votes are required for the Court to hear a case, so the recorded support of three justices was not enough, and the judgment of the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit — which upheld the California requirement — stands as the final word in the case.

50 hoursApproved continuing medical education California physicians must complete every two years
2019Year the California Legislature added the implicit-bias curriculum requirement
3Justices recorded against the denial — Thomas and Alito dissenting, Gorsuch would have granted

What California requires of its doctors

California-licensed physicians must complete 50 hours of approved continuing medical education, known as CME, every two years to keep their licences. Under section 2190.1(d)(1) of the California Business and Professions Code, added by the Legislature in 2019 and applicable to courses after January 1, 2022, every credit-eligible CME course must "contain curriculum that includes the understanding of implicit bias." A course can satisfy the rule in either of two ways: with examples of how implicit bias affects perceptions and treatment decisions of physicians and surgeons, leading to disparities in health outcomes, or with strategies to address how unintended biases in decisionmaking may contribute to health care disparities.

CME courses are often organised by private entities, certified by private accreditors and taught by private instructors, and the state does not preapprove course content, though it reserves the right to audit courses for compliance with its standards. The petitioners were Dr. Azadeh Khatibi, a California-licensed ophthalmologist who creates and teaches CME courses on topics such as retinal tumours and glaucoma, and Do No Harm, Inc., a Virginia-based nonprofit medical advocacy group. Their petition, filed on April 28, 2026, presented a single question: "Whether private instruction in courses required for state licensure constitutes government speech." The respondents, led by Felix C. Yip, are the state officials who administer the requirement.

Source: Reason — The Volokh Conspiracy

How the case travelled to the Supreme Court

Dr. Khatibi and Do No Harm argued that the mandate compels private instructors to deliver the state's preferred message, in violation of the First Amendment's protection of free speech. A federal district court dismissed the challenge on May 2, 2024, and on July 25, 2025, the Ninth Circuit affirmed, holding that all three factors from the Supreme Court's Shurtleff decision indicate that CME courses eligible for state credit constitute government speech — a category of speech the government may control without First Amendment scrutiny. Pacific Legal Foundation represented the petitioners free of charge; the foundation noted that Dr. Khatibi fled Iran as a child before building her medical career in the United States.

Source: Pacific Legal Foundation

Justice Thomas, dissenting

"A State cannot regulate its way out of First Amendment scrutiny." Justice Thomas wrote that California's requirement "is not speech by any government actor; it is a requirement that private speakers communicate certain messages," and warned that the government-speech doctrine should not be wielded as "a cover for censorship." He concluded: "I would grant certiorari to correct course."

What Monday's denial does — and does not — decide

A denial of certiorari is not a ruling on the merits and is not an endorsement of the California requirement; the Court decided nothing about whether the mandate is constitutional. The practical effect is narrower but immediate: the Ninth Circuit's ruling and California's implicit-bias training requirement remain in effect, and the case is over. Every California physician — including the state's large community of immigrant and South Asian doctors, among them many Punjabi physicians practising across the Central Valley and Southern California — must continue to take licensure courses that include the mandated curriculum. Similar professional-training mandates exist elsewhere, including Michigan's implicit-bias training rule for health professions, and Monday's lineup signals that at least three justices are interested in the underlying question if a suitable case reaches them from another circuit.

What happens next

There is no further appeal from a denial of certiorari, so California's Medical Board will continue enforcing the requirement as before, and course providers must keep building the implicit-bias curriculum into every credit-eligible class. The legal fight is likely to move rather than end: because the Supreme Court left the Ninth Circuit's government-speech reasoning standing without endorsing it, challengers can bring a fresh case in a different federal circuit and hope for a split that forces the justices to take up the question. For now, doctors renewing a California licence face exactly the same 50-hour requirement, with the same mandated content, as they did before Monday's order.