A Colorado State University police sergeant who shot and wounded an armed student on the Fort Collins campus last month will not face criminal charges. In findings released on Monday, November 16, Eighth Judicial District Attorney Gordon P. McLaughlin determined that CSU Police Sergeant Wil Nichols was legally justified in firing at 22-year-old Brooks Bottenhorn during the October 12 confrontation outside the university's Microbiology Building, North Forty News reported. Television station 9News also reported that the Larimer County District Attorney's Office ruled the officer's use of force justified.
Source: North Forty News — district attorney findings, November 16, 2026
The decision closes the criminal review of the officer. It does not close the case against the student: Bottenhorn still faces six criminal charges from the same evening, and prosecutors deliberately limited some details in their November 16 report to protect those ongoing proceedings.
What happened on the evening of October 12
According to the district attorney's report, CSU police received multiple calls at around 5:35 p.m. on October 12 reporting a man screaming, behaving erratically and striking a window near the Microbiology Building at 401 W. Pitkin Street on the university's main campus in Fort Collins, Colorado.
Sergeant Nichols arrived approximately 14 minutes later. He responded alone because another high-priority police situation was underway elsewhere on campus, and the initial calls had not indicated that a weapon was involved, the report said.
Nichols' body-worn camera footage, reviewed by investigators, showed Bottenhorn striking the building's glass entrance. Approximately nine seconds after Nichols stepped out of his patrol vehicle, a gunshot could be heard coming from Bottenhorn's direction. The earlier Critical Incident Response Team (CIRT) update said Bottenhorn fired a round into the Microbiology Building before turning toward the sergeant.
Source: City of Fort Collins — CIRT update, October 16, 2026
Bottenhorn then advanced toward Nichols while holding a handgun. Nichols drew his firearm and ordered him to put the weapon down and raise his hands. According to the report, Bottenhorn kept approaching while yelling, and his right hand began raising the handgun from his waist toward the officer. Nichols fired four shots in rapid succession from about 28 feet away, striking Bottenhorn in his right arm. Bottenhorn fell, his handgun landed nearby, and Nichols stopped firing. Investigators could not conclusively determine whether Bottenhorn intentionally released the handgun or lost his grip because of the gunfire and movement.
The CIRT update issued in October said the sergeant immediately rendered first aid and Bottenhorn was taken to an area hospital with serious injuries; he was expected to survive. University officials emphasised at the time that the incident was not an active-shooter event.
Source: City of Fort Collins — CIRT update, October 16, 2026
Why prosecutors cleared the sergeant
The Eighth Judicial District Critical Incident Response Team reviewed the body-camera footage, witness statements, physical evidence, scene documentation and ballistics testing. Fort Collins Police Services led the investigation, with assistance from the Larimer County Sheriff's Office, the Loveland Police Department, the CSU Police Department, the Estes Park Police Department and the district attorney's office.
McLaughlin's report explained a legal point that decided how the case was judged: because Bottenhorn survived, the shooting was evaluated under Colorado's general physical-force standard, rather than the statutory definition of deadly physical force, which requires that a death occur. The review weighed whether nonviolent alternatives were available, whether the officer faced an imminent threat, and whether the force used met the legal requirements. McLaughlin concluded that Nichols acted lawfully to protect himself and others nearby, and to arrest Bottenhorn, and that his actions complied with Colorado law governing police use of force.
The district attorney's findings end the criminal review of Sergeant Nichols only. They are not a verdict in the student's case: Brooks Bottenhorn is presumed innocent unless and until he is proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.
The six charges against the student remain
Prosecutors filed six charges against Bottenhorn after the confrontation: criminal mischief, a Class 6 felony; menacing, a Class 5 felony; illegal discharge of a firearm, a Class 5 felony; unlawful carrying of a weapon, a Class 1 misdemeanour; prohibited use of a weapon, a Class 1 misdemeanour; and reckless endangerment, a Class 2 misdemeanour.
Source: The Rocky Mountain Collegian — suspect charges and bond, October 2026
In October, the Rocky Mountain Collegian reported that a judge set Bottenhorn's bond at $15,000, ordered him to stay away from the CSU campus and barred him from possessing weapons, drugs or alcohol; 9News reported his attorney said he was seeking mental-health treatment. He later bonded out of jail. Those October court conditions were reported at the time; the district attorney's November report does not update them.
Source: The Rocky Mountain Collegian — suspect charges and bond, October 2026
What happens next
For Sergeant Nichols, the criminal file is closed: no charges will be filed against him. For Bottenhorn, the criminal case in Larimer County remains pending, and future court dates and any plea or trial decisions will decide it. The district attorney's office has said its report intentionally held back some details while that case is alive, so the full public record of the October 12 confrontation will only emerge through the student's court proceedings.
