DENVER, Colorado — The U.S. Department of Homeland Security asked a panel of the Tenth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Monday, November 16, 2026, to lift a preliminary injunction that limits how Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers can make arrests without a warrant in Colorado, in oral arguments in the class action Ramirez Ovando, et al. v. Mullin, et al. The panel heard the government's appeal and the plaintiffs' defence of the order, questioned both sides closely, and set no date for its decision, according to Courthouse News Service reporting of the hearing.

Source: Courthouse News Service

The injunction, issued on November 25, 2025, by U.S. District Judge R. Brooke Jackson in Denver, bars ICE from arresting anyone in Colorado without a warrant unless the arresting officer first makes the probable-cause findings federal law requires — that the person is in the United States in violation of immigration law and is likely to escape before a warrant can be obtained — and documents that assessment. The appeal, docketed in the Tenth Circuit as No. 26-1027, comes from the district court case No. 1:25-cv-03183-RBJ.

Source: ACLU of Colorado

What the government argued

Arguing for the government, attorney Daniel Mummolo told the panel that the district court's order forces the court to monitor every warrantless immigration arrest in the state, which he called an overreach. He argued that the Department of Homeland Security is not required to produce evidence of compliance beyond its written policy — in other words, that the agency's stated policy should be enough, without case-by-case proof that officers are actually completing the assessments before arrests.

The judges pressed that point. Judge Joel Carson pressed the government to produce evidence that the assessments are being performed. Judge Harris Hartz asked whether agents are equipped with body cameras that could document compliance. The panel's questions suggested the court may allow the government to present compliance evidence later in the case, Courthouse News reported. No justice of the panel committed to an outcome in open court, and a decision date was not announced.

What the plaintiffs argued

For the plaintiffs, ACLU attorney Timothy Macdonald asked the panel to keep the injunction in place, arguing that the plaintiffs must show a likelihood of success on the merits and that the government has not demonstrated that its agents are following the assessment requirement. The plaintiffs' position, as set out in their filings, is that a written policy on paper means little if officers in the field are not making — and recording — the individualized flight-risk finding the statute requires before a warrantless arrest.

The law behind the case

The legal standard at the centre of the case is in federal statute, 8 U.S.C. 1357(a)(2). It allows an immigration officer to arrest a person without a warrant only where the officer has reason to believe the person is in the United States in violation of immigration law and is likely to escape before a warrant can be obtained. The ACLU of Colorado says that individualized probable-cause requirement has been in federal law for about 80 years, and that the lawsuit is about whether ICE in Colorado has been following it.

The rule in one line

Under the injunction now under appeal, an ICE officer in Colorado may not make a warrantless arrest without first finding probable cause that the person is in the country in violation of immigration law AND is likely to flee before a warrant can be obtained — and that finding must be documented.

How the case began: four arrests

The class action was filed on October 9, 2025, by the ACLU of Colorado with the Meyer Law Office and Olson Grimsley Kawanabe Hinchcliff & Murray, LLC, on behalf of four named plaintiffs. According to the lawsuit, lead plaintiff Refugio Ramirez Ovando has lived in the United States for 20 years, has U.S. citizen children and is an active member of his church community; ICE agents pulled him over on his way to work and detained him even though, the suit says, they admitted they were searching for someone else. Caroline Dias Goncalves, a nursing student at the University of Utah, was pulled over by a Mesa County sheriff's officer who, the suit says, aided ICE in her arrest. J.S.T., in Colorado for 15 years, was arrested at his apartment complex on his way to the job he had held for ten years. G.R.R., in the U.S. for more than 10 years, was arrested in a nightclub raid where he was waiting as a designated driver. In each case, the plaintiffs say, ICE had no warrant and made no flight-risk inquiry before taking them into custody — allegations the district court credited when it found each named plaintiff had been unlawfully arrested.

A judge already found the order was violated

The appeal is not happening in a vacuum. After a two-day evidentiary hearing on March 10 and 11, 2026 — at which the court heard from three ICE deportation officers and the acting ICE field office director in Colorado — Judge Jackson ruled on May 12, 2026, that the government had materially violated the preliminary injunction. The enforcement order required ICE to train its officers in how to make warrantless arrests lawfully, with all officers trained within 45 days or barred from making warrantless arrests in the District of Colorado, and required ICE to hand plaintiffs' counsel documentation of future warrantless arrests and so-called field-warrant arrests so compliance could be monitored, according to the court's order and the ACLU's case record.

Source: U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado, Order Enforcing Preliminary Injunction, May 12, 2026 (via CourtListener)

The plaintiffs have since alleged continued noncompliance. In an August 26, 2026, status report and notice of noncompliance — the plaintiffs' filing, which the government disputes in the litigation — they said a review of about three months of ICE document production showed continued warrantless arrests without the required flight-risk analysis, arrests carried out under improper field warrants, arrests of the wrong person, inaccurate reporting and missing documents. The filing also alleged violent arrests, including of an 18-year-old who, the plaintiffs say, was hospitalized with facial lacerations, a black eye and a broken wrist. Those are the plaintiffs' allegations in a court filing, not findings the appeals court has adopted. On September 25, 2026, the district court ruled on the government's motion for reconsideration and issued a further order on the compliance issues.

Oct 9, 2025Class action filed in Denver
Nov 25, 2025Preliminary injunction issued
May 12, 2026Court finds material violation
Nov 16, 2026Tenth Circuit oral argument
26-1027Tenth Circuit appeal number

Why this matters beyond Colorado

For immigrant communities — including Colorado's Punjabi diaspora families, workers and truckers who cross the state on corridors such as I-70 and I-25 — the case decides a practical question that comes up in traffic stops, workplace visits and home arrests: what must an ICE officer actually establish, and write down, before taking someone into custody without a judge-signed warrant? If the injunction stands, the assessment-and-documentation requirement remains the operating rule in Colorado and every warrantless arrest generates a paper record lawyers can test in court. If it is lifted, warrantless arrests in the state could proceed without that mandated assessment, with fewer procedural safeguards for the person detained, as Courthouse News summarized the stakes. The same statutory language governs warrantless immigration arrests nationwide, so lawyers in other states are watching how the Tenth Circuit reads it.

What happens next

The Tenth Circuit panel has taken the appeal under advisement and set no decision date. The government's opening brief was filed on June 1, 2026, and the plaintiffs' answer brief on August 31, 2026, so the case is fully briefed and now awaits the panel's ruling. Unless and until the appeals court orders otherwise, Judge Jackson's preliminary injunction — and the May 12, 2026, enforcement order built on it — remains the governing rule for warrantless ICE arrests in Colorado. A ruling for the government would lift those limits; a ruling for the plaintiffs would keep them in place while the underlying class action continues in district court. Awaaz Punjab will update this story when the panel rules.

What is solid

  • Oral argument in the Tenth Circuit appeal was held on November 16, 2026, and the panel set no decision date (Courthouse News Service; ACLU of Colorado case page).
  • Judge Jackson issued the preliminary injunction on November 25, 2025, and found a material violation of it on May 12, 2026 (court orders).

What is only claimed

  • Whether ICE officers in Colorado are in fact completing the required flight-risk assessments — the government says its written policy suffices; the plaintiffs say field practice and the document production show otherwise.
  • The plaintiffs' August 2026 allegations of continued noncompliance and violent arrests, which are claims in a court filing and have not been adopted as findings by the appeals court.