A Cuban family released at the U.S. border on Form I-220A was never “paroled into the United States” and cannot use that release to get a green card under the Cuban Adjustment Act, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit ruled on Monday, November 17. In Aguiar-Fernandez v. U.S. Attorney General, No. 24-12318, a panel of Judges Elizabeth Branch, Andrew Brasher and Frank Hull denied the family's petition for review in a 16-page published opinion written by Judge Brasher. No judge wrote separately.
Source: Eleventh Circuit opinion, reported by Immigration Analytics
The ruling matters far beyond one family. Tens of thousands of Cubans who crossed the southern border since 2021 were released on I-220A forms — an Order of Release on Recognizance — instead of being paroled, and many of them live in Florida. The Eleventh Circuit is the court that hears most Cuban Adjustment Act cases, and this is its first published decision on the question. An unpublished February 2026 decision from the same court had remanded groups of I-220A cases without deciding whether an I-220A is parole, leaving families and lawyers in limbo; Monday's published opinion now gives immigration judges and USCIS in Florida, Georgia and Alabama a binding answer.
How the Aguiar-Fernandez family got here
According to the opinion, Yoan Aguiar-Fernandez, his wife and their daughter entered the United States near San Luis, Arizona, on June 25, 2021, and turned themselves in to Border Patrol. Each received a Form I-220A citing 8 U.S.C. 1226 and a notice to appear charging them as present without admission or parole. They conceded removability, applied for asylum, withholding of removal and protection under the Convention Against Torture, filed Cuban Adjustment Act applications, and separately asked the Department of Homeland Security for humanitarian parole. DHS denied the parole request.
An immigration judge found the family credible but set their Cuban Adjustment applications aside — pretermitted them — reasoning that they had been released on conditional parole rather than humanitarian parole. The judge also denied asylum, withholding and torture protection and ordered the family removed. The Board of Immigration Appeals affirmed without an opinion, so the Eleventh Circuit reviewed the immigration judge's decision directly.
Why the court said an I-220A is not parole
The Cuban Adjustment Act, a 1966 law, lets a Cuban national adjust to permanent residence if he or she was “inspected and admitted or paroled into the United States” and has been physically present for at least a year. The panel read “paroled into the United States” in that Act to mean humanitarian parole under 8 U.S.C. 1182(d)(5)(A) — the same reading courts have given the same phrase in the general adjustment statute — following the Second Circuit's 2011 decision in Cruz-Miguel v. Holder and citing the Third Circuit, the Ninth Circuit and the Board's own Matter of Castillo-Padilla. The “conditional parole” in section 1226, by contrast, uses different words and does a different job: release under it “may be a type of generic parole,” Judge Brasher wrote, but it does not authorize parole into the United States. The opinion puts its holding in one line: release under section 1226's conditional parole provision “does not suffice.”
The family's main argument was that, as border arrivals, they were subject to mandatory detention under a different provision, 8 U.S.C. 1225(b)(2)(A), and that the only lawful way to release such a person is humanitarian parole — so they must have been paroled as a matter of law. The court rejected that. Whether DHS granted humanitarian parole “is a question of historical fact,” the panel held, and it turns on the reason the agency actually gave, not on which detention statute should have applied. Here, the court said, the record was clear: the I-220As cited section 1226, the family's own green card applications listed the I-220As as the basis for their presence, no Form I-94 parole document was ever issued, and DHS had expressly denied their requests for humanitarian parole.
The court also upheld the denial of asylum and other protection. The family's claims rested on a 2016 dispute with a Cuban police captain after Aguiar-Fernandez returned from a government mission in Venezuela. The panel found that he and his wife were not arrested or interrogated afterward and kept their jobs, that the record suggests the captain acted in a private capacity, and that the incidents did not rise to persecution in any event, applying the deferential substantial-evidence standard.
It does not hold that every I-220A holder is removable — it addresses Cuban Adjustment eligibility based on an I-220A release alone. It leaves room for cases where the record is ambiguous about why DHS released someone. And it does not resolve Bello-Rubio v. Noem, the Southern District of Florida suit by roughly 992 Cubans with I-220As, which remains pending before Judge Jacqueline Becerra.
The decision lines up with the position immigration authorities have taken for years. The Board of Immigration Appeals adopted the same view in its 2023 precedent decision, Matter of Cabrera-Fernandez, holding that release under section 1226 is legally distinct from humanitarian parole, and immigration judges have relied on it to find I-220A holders ineligible to adjust, CubaHeadlines reported in its explainer on the I-220A landscape. The February 2026 unpublished Eleventh Circuit decision had briefly opened a door by sending two Cuban families' cases back to the Board after the government changed its position on which detention statute applied; Monday's published ruling closes that uncertainty for cases where, as here, the release paperwork clearly cites section 1226.
Source: CubaHeadlines
What happens next
Several dates and decisions now matter. A petition for rehearing is generally due 45 days after judgment when the United States is a party — about January 1, 2027. In Miami, Judge Becerra still has to rule on the government's second motion to dismiss in Bello-Rubio, the case brought by roughly 992 Cubans. And lawyers across Florida will be watching whether USCIS and the immigration courts begin citing Aguiar-Fernandez to set aside pending I-220A adjustment cases. For families holding an I-220A, the practical lesson from the opinion is documentary: parole is now a question of fact decided by the paperwork — an I-94 or a parole grant citing section 1182(d)(5)(A) counts, an I-220A citing section 1226, after this ruling, does not. Affected families may need to pursue asylum or other relief, a fresh humanitarian parole request, or a path that does not depend on the I-220A release itself.
