Four men have been charged in the kidnapping and murder of Jim Johnson Jr., an Orlando man who disappeared from a barbershop in December 2013 and whose body was found in Daytona Beach five days later. Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier and Orlando Police Chief Eric Smith announced the charges on Thursday, November 19, 2026, closing a case that had stayed unsolved for almost 13 years.
The men charged are Carlton Leon Williams, 50, of Orlando; Derrick Lineil Dean, 47, of Orlando; Sean Quentin Daniel Cosby Davis, 35, of Orlando; and Nathaniel Webster, 42, of Altamonte Springs. They face charges including first-degree felony murder, kidnapping, armed robbery with a firearm, armed burglary, aggravated battery with a firearm, grand theft of an automobile and racketeering. The men are accused; none of the charges has been proven in court, and no trial has taken place.
What happened in 2013
Johnson was abducted from Goolie's Barbershop on South Orange Blossom Trail in Orlando at around 9:15 a.m. on December 6, 2013. Witnesses said he disappeared from the rear of the business, where investigators later found a significant bloodstain near where his vehicle had been parked. His body was recovered on December 11, 2013, in a wooded area near Daytona Beach, and his death was ruled a homicide.
Investigators connected the kidnapping to a violent home-invasion robbery in which armed suspects allegedly forced their way into a residence, shot another victim in the leg, and emptied a concealed floor safe containing cash and valuables. Prosecutors describe the kidnapping and the home invasion as part of one planned criminal enterprise, not a random act of violence.
How the case was cracked
The breakthrough came through a cold-case initiative the Attorney General's office launched about a year ago. The investigation was run by the Orlando Police Department's Cold Case Homicide Unit and the Office of Statewide Prosecution's Cold Case Investigation Unit, with help from the Orange County Sheriff's Office and the Daytona Beach Police Department. Investigators revisited the old evidence and used new DNA techniques and cellphone record analysis to build a timeline linking the suspects to one another and to the area where Johnson's body was found. Uthmeier said investigators were able to trace telephone communications to the location where the body was found.
"After more than a decade, justice is finally coming for Jim Johnson Jr. and his family. This was not a random act of violence — it was a planned kidnapping and home invasion robbery that was carried out by a criminal enterprise and ended in murder."
Three of the suspects were arrested by Orlando police's fugitive unit and SWAT team. The fourth turned himself in. Prosecutors said they plan to present the case to a grand jury in the coming weeks and intend to seek indictments. The case is being prosecuted in Florida's Ninth Judicial Circuit, and officials said some additional alleged crimes tied to the suspects remain under investigation.
What is solid
- Four men have been charged in the 2013 kidnapping and murder of Jim Johnson Jr., as announced by the Attorney General and Orlando police on November 19, 2026.
- Johnson disappeared from Goolie's Barbershop on December 6, 2013, and his body was found near Daytona Beach on December 11, 2013; his death was ruled a homicide.
- Investigators used DNA analysis and cellphone records to connect the suspects to the case.
What is only claimed
- Whether the four men committed the crimes as charged — that is for a grand jury and, if indicted, a trial to decide. All four are presumed innocent unless proven guilty.
- The full scope of the alleged criminal enterprise, including the additional alleged crimes officials say remain under investigation.
For Johnson's family, the announcement ends nearly 13 years of waiting. Ryan Backman, executive director of Project Cold Case, said Johnson's sister, Melody, continued seeking answers for the family through the years the case stayed unsolved. Cold cases like this one leave families in limbo for a decade or more, and the arrests are the first step toward a courtroom reckoning rather than the end of the process.
The case is also the first major result of Florida's statewide cold-case push. In April 2026, Uthmeier launched a statewide partnership to solve cold cases using advanced forensic DNA testing and genetic genealogy, working with the forensic technology company Othram and targeting more than 21,000 unsolved murders across Florida. The Johnson case was reopened under that initiative. What happens next is the grand jury: prosecutors will present the evidence in the coming weeks, and only an indictment will move the four men to trial.
