A lawsuit over mould and living conditions in privatised housing at MacDill Air Force Base in Tampa, Florida, has more than doubled in size, with 105 military families representing 454 people now alleging they lived in unsafe and unhealthy conditions, according to a second amended complaint filed in federal court late on Monday, November 16, and reporting by Tampa Bay 28's I-Team on November 17.
The 924-page amended complaint, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida in Tampa as Dillon and Leah Mullins, et al., v. The Michaels Organization, LLC, et al., Case No. 8:25-cv-02637-SDM-AAS, names The Michaels Organization, LLC, AMC East Communities, LLC and MMS Air Force, LLC as defendants. The Michaels Organization operates Harbor Bay at MacDill, the privatised on-base housing community at issue.
Source: Tampa Bay 28 I-Team
From 39 families to 105 in just over a year
Tampa Bay 28's I-Team first reported the lawsuit when it was filed in September 2025 with 39 families. The second amended complaint combines the families already before the court, families whose claims were pending in related cases, and new plaintiffs, as permitted by the court's September 15, 2026 order, the families' attorneys said in a November 17 release. The attorneys — Just Well Law, PLLC, Cooper & Kirk, PLLC and The McKee Law Group — said they believe it is the largest known military housing lawsuit in the nation; that description is the plaintiffs' attorneys' claim, not a court finding.
Source: PR Newswire / Just Well Law
What the families allege — and what has not been proven
The amended complaint alleges the families 'suffered physical, emotional, and other personal injuries as well as economic losses because they lived in unsafe and unhealthy conditions in privatised on-base military housing,' Tampa Bay 28 reported. It alleges the defendants' actions and failures in operating, managing and maintaining the housing created unsafe conditions, concealed those conditions through false or misleading statements, and failed to properly repair and remediate problems after families reported them. These are allegations in a civil complaint; they have not been proven in court, and no judge has ruled on them.
The claims listed in the case include breach of contract, negligence, gross negligence, breach of the warranty of habitability, breach of contracts made for the families' benefit, negligence per se, unjust enrichment, negligent misrepresentation, fraudulent inducement, fraudulent misrepresentation and fraudulent concealment, according to the attorneys' release.
Seven failed reviews and a federal criminal investigation
According to the complaint, The Michaels Organization 'failed seven consecutive quarterly performance reviews,' and the expanded complaint alleges the Air Force placed the defendants on a performance improvement plan. The complaint further alleges, on information and belief, that the Department of Defense and the Air Force have opened a criminal investigation into whether the defendants falsified work orders addressing mould at MacDill — work orders they were contractually obligated and paid to complete.
The families' attorneys said federal investigators are examining whether Michaels falsified the work orders it used to show mould problems were fixed, according to U.S. Representative Kathy Castor and U.S. Representative Gus Bilirakis and news reports. Tampa Bay 28 reported that members of Congress learned about the investigation and the failed performance reviews while demanding answers over conditions in MacDill housing. No criminal charge arising from that investigation was announced in the reporting reviewed for this story.
One family's account: a master sergeant who moved into a trailer
Among the families newly added are U.S. Air Force Master Sgt. Zachary Pletcher and his family. The I-Team introduced viewers to Pletcher in September, when he and his family were living in a trailer after moving out of base housing. Pletcher said at the time that his health had deteriorated to the point that he expected to leave the military earlier than planned. 'I have to leave the service much sooner than I ever thought I would,' he told the I-Team, describing severe tremors and weakness. Pletcher and his wife, Brandy, said mould in their base housing made them sick; Brandy Pletcher told the I-Team she relies on portable oxygen and has chronic respiratory failure with hypoxia, which her medical records attributed to mould exposure, according to Tampa Bay 28. Those health accounts are the family's statements as reported by the I-Team, not findings by the court.
The Michaels Organization told Tampa Bay 28: 'While we cannot comment on the specifics of ongoing litigation, our priority has always been and continues to be the well-being of our Harbor Bay residents, staff, and community. We continue to invest significant resources into our homes with a focus on customer service and quality control, and to work closely with the U.S. Air Force and Base Command to further strengthen how we communicate with residents and maintain our communities.'
Why MacDill matters beyond one housing community
MacDill Air Force Base, in Tampa on Florida's Gulf Coast, is home to U.S. Central Command and U.S. Special Operations Command, two of the most senior headquarters in the U.S. military. Housing there is run under the privatised military housing model, in which private companies operate and maintain on-base homes under long-term arrangements with the services. The case therefore reaches beyond one landlord dispute: it tests how complaints, repairs and performance reviews are handled for service families who have limited choice about where they live when posted to a base.
For readers in the Punjabi diaspora — including service families, veterans and the many truckers and workers who pass through the Tampa and central Florida corridors — the case is a reminder that a civil filing, a performance review and a criminal investigation are three different tracks. A complaint's allegations must still be tested through evidence, the defendants can answer and defend the claims, and a criminal investigation does not by itself establish that a crime was committed.
What happens next
The second amended complaint now sets the scope of the civil case in Tampa federal court: 105 households, with the experiences and alleged damages of each included in the filing. The defendants will have the opportunity to respond to the amended complaint, and the court will set the schedule for motions, evidence exchange and any trial. Separately, the reported federal criminal investigation into work orders and the Air Force's performance oversight of Harbor Bay housing will continue on their own tracks. Tampa Bay 28's I-Team said it has been investigating conditions in MacDill housing for more than a year, and families continue to come forward through that reporting.
What is solid
- Second amended complaint filed in Tampa federal court, Case No. 8:25-cv-02637-SDM-AAS, expanding the case to 105 families / 454 people (attorneys' release and Tampa Bay 28, Nov. 17)
- Defendants named: The Michaels Organization, LLC, AMC East Communities, LLC and MMS Air Force, LLC; Michaels operates Harbor Bay at MacDill
- The Michaels Organization gave Tampa Bay 28 a statement saying it cannot comment on specifics of ongoing litigation and that resident well-being is its priority
What is only claimed
- All claims about mould, unsafe conditions, concealment and falsified work orders are allegations in the complaint or in the plaintiffs' attorneys' release — not proven findings
- The plaintiffs' attorneys' description of the case as the largest known military housing lawsuit in the nation is their claim, not a court determination
