Two federal courts in two days have pushed back against the way U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) makes arrests. On Wednesday, November 18, a federal judge in Colorado held ICE officials in contempt of court for re-arresting immigrants within minutes of a judge ordering them freed. On Thursday, November 19, a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit pressed Justice Department lawyers over whether ICE agents need a judicial warrant before knocking on a person's door with the intent to make an arrest.

Neither ruling settles the underlying questions for good. The Colorado judge imposed no fine or other sanction, saying the agency had stopped the practice. The Ninth Circuit panel took the knock-and-talk case under submission and gave no indication of when it will rule. But together, the two days show the federal judiciary scrutinising ICE's arrest tactics more closely than at any point this year — and both developments matter directly for immigrant communities, including the large Punjabi diaspora in the western states covered by the Ninth Circuit.

18people in Colorado held too long or re-arrested within minutes of a court-ordered release in six weeks
15pages in Judge Sweeney's contempt ruling
9western states covered by the Ninth Circuit's coming decision

The Colorado contempt finding

U.S. District Judge Charlotte Sweeney of the District of Colorado issued the contempt finding in a 15-page ruling on November 18 in the case of Quintero Alvarez v. Baltazar. The case concerned Ramon Quintero Alvarez, who was born in Mexico and entered the United States with his mother in 1993 or 1994. He had filed a habeas corpus petition challenging his immigration detention. On October 20, Judge Sweeney ordered the government to answer his petition by October 27 or release him within 24 hours. The government did not file the required response, so Alvarez was released from immigration custody on October 27 — and ICE officers re-arrested him within minutes, after he had collected his belongings and stepped into a public area.

"ICE's new 'policy' of immediately re-detaining petitioners following release made a mockery of court orders mandating petitioners' immediate release," Judge Sweeney wrote, according to Colorado Public Radio and Reuters, which both reported on the ruling.

The practice was not limited to one man. Colorado Public Radio reported that at least 18 people in Colorado had been held in detention longer than judges ordered, or had been re-arrested within minutes of their judge-ordered release, in the previous six weeks. Government records identified 18 cases in which immigrants were re-detained within 12 hours of a court-ordered release on or after October 27, and immigration lawyers said the true number was probably higher because people representing themselves are harder to track.

Testimony at evidentiary hearings on November 4 and November 9 described how the practice worked. ICE Assistant Field Office Director Nichole Black told the judge she had received a direct order from her supervisor to carry out the instant re-arrests. Nathan Rasper, the acting director of ICE's Denver field office, testified that he had ordered the re-arrests himself. Rasper later swore in court that the practice had stopped — testimony Judge Sweeney said saved the government from greater consequences.

That is why the contempt finding carried no fine and no further sanction. "Given the (government) cured the contempt by ceasing the practice at issue, the court declines to take any further action," Judge Sweeney wrote. She closed the case, but warned in her ruling that if there were any more violations of release orders, she would not hesitate to reopen the matter. Other judges in the Colorado federal court have already begun requiring advance notice before any re-detention, and Senior Judge R. Brooke Jackson wrote in a separate order that "'Release' means 'release and let go,' not release and rearrest," according to Colorado Politics.

The Ninth Circuit hearing on 'knock-and-talk'

A day later, the focus moved west. A three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals heard the Justice Department's appeal of a district court order that blocked ICE's "knock-and-talk" policy. In a knock-and-talk, agents walk up to a home, knock, and ask questions — with no warrant. If the person inside opens the door and talks, agents can act on what they see and hear. The policy at issue originated in ICE's Los Angeles Field Office. A federal district court ruled in 2025 that ICE needs a judicial warrant, not merely an administrative warrant, to make arrests this way, finding the tactic likely violated the Fourth Amendment's limits on warrantless arrests at a residence. The Justice Department appealed.

During Thursday's hearing, the judges expressed considerable scepticism about the government's position. U.S. Circuit Judge Milan Smith Jr. pressed the government's lawyer on what happens when an officer arrives at a door with the explicit intention of making an arrest. U.S. Circuit Judge Danielle Forrest questioned how far an officer's implied licence to approach a home extends, suggesting it should be no greater than that of an ordinary member of the public. Deputy Assistant Attorney General Drew Ensign, arguing for the government, said the authority for administrative warrants has roots dating back to 1797. Jeremy Kreisberg, counsel for the immigrant groups challenging the policy, argued that the Fourth Amendment fundamentally requires a judicial warrant before law enforcement enters a home to make an arrest. The judges also pressed the challengers' lawyers on whether their organisations have standing to bring the case. The panel took the matter under submission.

The background to the case is a policy that was kept from public view for months. In May 2025, ICE secretly implemented a policy — later revealed by a whistleblower — instructing officers that administrative warrants authorised them not only to approach homes to make arrests but to forcibly enter those homes. The agency says it has since paused that policy, but insists it retains the power to restart it. Civil-rights groups argued in a court filing that administrative warrants are issued by executive-branch supervisory officers who are not neutral decision-makers, and that ICE's own Fugitive Operations Handbook once stated plainly that an administrative warrant does not authorise officers to enter a home.

Why this matters for immigrants — including in the West

The Ninth Circuit's eventual decision will apply across nine western states, including California, Washington and Oregon — home to some of the largest Punjabi and South Asian communities in the United States, and to many of the truck drivers, farm workers and small-business owners who read this site. A ruling that tightens the rules would change how ICE operates at front doors across the West overnight; a ruling for the government would leave the current playbook intact.

The two cases also draw a line that matters in everyday encounters. A judicial warrant is signed by a judge after a finding of probable cause. An administrative warrant — the Form I-200 arrest warrant or Form I-205 removal warrant — is issued inside the executive branch, by immigration officials themselves. The Colorado and Ninth Circuit cases are both, at their core, about whether the government can treat the second kind of paper as if it were the first.

What happens next

What happens next: the Ninth Circuit panel gave no date for its ruling. In Colorado, Judge Sweeney's warning stands — any further violation of a release order would bring the matter back before her court, and other Colorado judges are already requiring advance notice before any re-detention. Awaaz Punjab will report the Ninth Circuit's decision when it comes.

Earlier: the November 9 hearing

Awaaz Punjab reported on November 9 that ICE's Denver chief had admitted under oath that he ordered the instant re-arrests, and that Judge Sweeney was considering a contempt finding. Wednesday's ruling is the outcome of that hearing. Read the earlier report