A 21-year-old Idaho man who plotted to attack churches in his home town in the name of the Islamic State group was sentenced on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, to 18 years in federal prison, followed by lifetime supervised release.
Source: Associated Press
U.S. District Judge David C. Nye imposed the sentence on Alexander Scott Mercurio of Coeur d'Alene, who pleaded guilty last month to attempting to provide material support and resources to the Islamic State group — known as ISIS or IS — a designated foreign terrorist organisation. The charge carried a maximum of 20 years.
Arrested one day before the planned attack
Prosecutors said Mercurio pledged his allegiance to IS and planned to attack churches in Coeur d'Alene on the group's behalf, using explosives, knives, firearms and other weapons. The FBI arrested him on April 6, 2024 — when he was 18 — one day before the planned April 7 attack, according to prosecutors and court records.
According to court records reported by The Center Square, Mercurio's plan was to incapacitate his father by hitting him with a metal pipe, steal his father's firearms, and carry out a mass-casualty attack on local churches using flame-covered weapons, explosives, knives and a machete. A search of his home found butane canisters, lighters, handcuffs, a knife, a machete and several firearms belonging to his father.
The FBI's Joint Terrorism Task Force led the investigation that stopped the plot, working with the Coeur d'Alene Police Department and the sheriff's offices of Kootenai County and Ada County, the U.S. Attorney's office said.
From an online repository to a pledge video
Court records say Mercurio created an online repository in early 2023 to distribute pro-IS content and spread the group's doctrine. He originally wanted to travel overseas to support the organisation but lacked the money and resources, prosecutors said. Shortly before his arrest, he gave a government informant an audio recording pledging his support for IS, along with a photograph of himself holding a knife in front of an IS flag.
“Sends the clear message that where individuals intend to pursue acts of terrorism against the United States — whether in Coeur d'Alene, or any other community — they will be brought to justice,” Idaho U.S. Attorney John Shirts said of the sentence.
The defence case: a depressed, isolated teenager
Mercurio's defence attorneys, Carter Powers Beggs and J. Stephen Roberts Jr. of the Federal Defenders of Eastern Washington and Idaho, declined to comment after sentencing. In court filings reported by AP, they described Mercurio as a depressed teenager when he was arrested, raised in a dysfunctional family that exposed him to white supremacist ideology at a young age, and isolated from the outside world when he was befriended online by a government informant.
“Starting when he was just seventeen years old, Mr. Mercurio spent his days holed away in his basement bedroom, talking with his best friend about increasingly radical terrorist ideologies,” his attorneys wrote. “Together they brainstormed a plan that was as horrific as it was unlikely to succeed: a suicidal attack on local churches using his father's firearms and an untested improvised explosive/flamethrower.” The defence said Mercurio has since renounced his extremist views and has been assessed as a low risk of future danger, and asked the judge for nine years. Judge Nye imposed eighteen.
Background: the group he tried to serve
The Islamic State group seized a large swath of territory in Syria and Iraq in 2014 and declared it a caliphate. It was largely defeated in both countries by 2018, but sleeper cells still carry out attacks there and IS affiliates operate in West Africa, AP noted. U.S. prosecutors have continued to bring material-support cases against people inside the United States accused of acting on the group's propaganda — and, as this case shows, courts treat a locally planned attack in a small Idaho city with the same seriousness as one aimed at a major metro.
What happens next
Mercurio, who has already spent more than two years in custody since his April 2024 arrest, will serve his sentence in the federal prison system, where there is no parole and prisoners generally serve at least 85 per cent of their term. When he is eventually released, he will remain on supervised release for the rest of his life, under conditions the court can enforce with a return to prison for violations.
