CHICAGO, Illinois — A Cook County judge has thrown out the murder conviction of Anthony Garrett, ruling on Monday, November 16, that the handwritten confession at the heart of his case was more likely than not obtained through torture. Circuit Judge Adrienne E. Davis vacated both the conviction and the sentence, suppressed the confession, and ordered a new trial in the 1992 killing of a 7-year-old boy who was shot while walking to school in Chicago's Cabrini-Green neighbourhood.

Source: Chicago Sun-Times, CBS Chicago and FOX 32 Chicago reporting, via FetchLens

Garrett, now 68, was convicted by a jury in 1994 and sentenced to 100 years in prison. He had been scheduled for release in 2039. After Monday's ruling he was transferred from state prison to the Cook County Jail, where he remains detained. A hearing is set for December 7 on a possible prosecution appeal and on whether Garrett will remain in custody while the State's Attorney's office decides whether to retry a case that is now more than three decades old.

1992Year of the Cabrini-Green shooting
100 yearsSentence imposed in 1994, now vacated
37 pagesLength of Judge Davis's ruling, as reported
Dec. 7Next hearing, on appeal and detention

What the judge found

Davis reached her decision after a months-long evidentiary hearing into Garrett's claim that his confession was coerced. In her ruling, as reported from the decision, she wrote: “The court finds Detective Zuley not credible.” Richard Zuley, the former Chicago police detective who was the arresting officer and a key witness in Garrett's case, denied knowing of any abuse. He testified that he left other detectives in charge overnight and that Garrett confessed the next morning, saying he had been shooting at rival gang members, before signing a handwritten statement.

Garrett's lawyers asserted that Zuley arranged for Garrett to be beaten while he was shackled to an eyebolt in an interview room. They connected that claim to allegations of coercion in other cases involving Zuley and to testimony about Zuley's later work as an interrogator at the U.S. detention facility at Guantánamo Bay, Cuba. Prosecutors urged the judge to disregard allegations from other cases, arguing they did not establish what happened to Garrett himself. They also questioned Garrett's account of the beating, including how his description changed over time, and cited testimony that he did not appear injured afterward.

Vacated is not exonerated

Monday's ruling wipes out Garrett's conviction and bars the state from using the suppressed confession, but it does not declare him innocent. Prosecutors must now decide whether they can — or should — try the 1992 case again without the confession that anchored the original trial.

The night in custody, as the record describes it

The Illinois Torture Inquiry and Relief Commission (TIRC), which referred Garrett's claim for judicial review in 2023, reconstructed the custody timeline from the case record: detectives took Garrett into custody on the afternoon of October 13, 1992, hours after the shooting; he was formally arrested at about 9 p.m. and held overnight in an interview room at the Area 6 police station at Western and Belmont. Garrett has alleged consistently since his indictment that two unknown officers beat him while he was held there. The alleged confession came the next morning, October 14, at about 9:30 a.m., and at about 2:30 p.m. he signed a statement — handwritten by an assistant state's attorney — confessing to the killing.

Source: Illinois Torture Inquiry and Relief Commission, Garrett determination (2023)

The commission found “overwhelming” pattern-and-practice evidence behind the referral: Zuley was the arresting officer, a key trial witness and a grand jury witness in Garrett's case, and detainees in a string of other Chicago cases between 1987 and 2003 alleged coercion of the same nature involving him. The commission also noted that a United States Senate report on Guantánamo named Zuley in connection with interrogation tactics used on a detainee there. At the same time, the commission recorded the factors weighing against Garrett — including the lack of physical evidence or contemporaneous documentation of abuse, and inconsistencies in his own accounts — before concluding that, on balance, there was sufficient evidence of torture to merit judicial review, particularly because the judge at Garrett's original suppression hearing never heard the evidence about Zuley's history.

A detective whose cases keep coming back

Garrett's is not the first Zuley case to collapse. Reporting on the evidentiary hearing noted that judges have previously vacated at least four other murder convictions involving Zuley. Zuley, who joined the Chicago Police Department in 1970 and worked more than three decades in it, testified for the prosecution in Garrett's hearing as part of State's Attorney Eileen O'Neill Burke's effort to block a retrial, insisting that rapport-building — not threats or force — is what produces reliable information. Garrett's attorneys were blocked by the federal administration from questioning him about his Guantánamo work, according to that reporting.

Why this matters beyond one case

The ruling is the latest chapter in Chicago's long reckoning with coerced confessions — cases in which a signed statement, obtained in an unrecorded interview room, sent a person to prison for decades before courts revisited how it was taken. Illinois created the torture commission precisely for claims of this kind, and its referral process is what brought Garrett's 1992 confession back in front of a judge more than 30 years later. For Cook County, the practical question now is stark: the physical evidence and witness memories of 1992 have faded, the confession is suppressed, and any retrial would have to be built without it.

What happens next

The December 7 hearing will address a possible prosecution appeal and Garrett's detention status. Prosecutors must then decide whether to retry him. If they do, the case returns to court as a new trial on a 1992 shooting, with the confession excluded. If they do not, a man who has spent more than three decades in prison on a vacated 100-year sentence will walk free — still never having been declared innocent by any court. Awaaz Punjab will follow the December hearing and the State's Attorney's decision.