Two young men have been arrested in Indianapolis after an Indiana State Police investigation into a scam that police say cost a 73-year-old Jackson County woman a large sum of money she handed over, in cash, to a man posing as a federal agent outside a McDonald's in Brownstown.
Source: Indiana State Police statement, reported by 812Now (Nov 18, 2026)
Sarwan Singh, 24, and Sajanpreet Singh, 23, were both arrested in Indianapolis this past weekend, the Indiana State Police said. Both are accused of fraud and theft, and police said additional charges are possible. The accusations are allegations; neither man has been convicted, and both are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.
How the scam worked, according to police
The scam started when the 73-year-old woman received an alert on her laptop claiming to be from Microsoft, police said. She clicked on the link, which put her in contact with someone who claimed that the money in her bank account was not safe.
The suspects convinced the woman to withdraw a large sum of money and transfer it to a “federal agent” at the McDonald's in Brownstown, according to the state police. The woman went to the restaurant and handed over the money. She later realised she had likely been scammed, and the Indiana State Police were contacted. Police have not publicly disclosed the amount of money involved, describing it only as a large sum.
Restaurant footage and a licence-plate reader
Trooper Tia Hunt launched an investigation in September. With assistance from the restaurant, Hunt was able to obtain footage of the alleged suspect and a vehicle, police said. A Flock licence plate reader was then used, which allowed police to identify the owner of the vehicle.
The investigation continued, and Hunt was able to confirm the identities of two suspects believed to have scammed the woman, according to the ISP. “Trp. Hunt was able to identify Sajanpreet Singh as the alleged suspect who met the victim to collect the money,” the state police said. Both men were arrested in Indianapolis this past weekend.
The Brownstown case follows a script consumer-protection and police agencies describe again and again: a fake computer alert, a warning that bank money is “not safe,” and an in-person cash handover to someone posing as a government agent. Microsoft does not send pop-up alerts asking users to call and move money, and no real federal agent will ask a resident to withdraw cash and hand it over at a restaurant or store.
The wider pattern in Indiana
Federal prosecutors in the Midwest have brought a series of cases built on the same pattern. In one Southern District of Illinois case, a courier for an imposter-scam conspiracy was convicted of collecting cash from elderly victims in Illinois, Indiana and Wisconsin, with victims defrauded of more than $400,000, according to the U.S. Department of Justice. In central Indiana, a man was sentenced on November 16, 2026, to 96 months in federal prison for conspiracy to commit money laundering after posing as a federal agent in pop-up scams that took gold and cash from elderly residents in Westfield and Carmel, according to WIBC reporting of that sentencing. Police have not said the Brownstown arrests are connected to those cases; they are separate prosecutions that investigators cite as the same method.
Why this matters beyond Jackson County
Brownstown is the county seat of Jackson County in southern Indiana, and scams aimed at older residents living on savings are among the most reported frauds in the state. For Punjabi and other immigrant families in Indiana — including many in Indianapolis, about an hour north of Brownstown — cases like this one carry a second lesson: elderly parents and grandparents are the usual targets, and a two-minute family conversation about never moving money on the strength of a computer pop-up or a phone call can be the difference between savings kept and savings lost.
What happens next
Both men are accused of fraud and theft, and the state police said additional charges are possible. Police also believe this investigation may assist other agencies in Indiana and Ohio in solving similar crimes, which suggests investigators are comparing the Brownstown handover against unsolved reports elsewhere. Formal court proceedings in Jackson County are the next step; anyone who was asked to hand over cash in a similar way is urged by police practice in these cases to contact their local police or the Indiana State Police rather than the number shown in a pop-up.
