A divided U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 on Tuesday, November 17, that prediction-market operator Kalshi cannot stop Maryland gaming regulators from pursuing enforcement action against it for offering sports event contracts without a state licence — deepening a national split over who polices the fast-growing prediction-market industry.

The Richmond, Virginia-based court affirmed the U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland, which in August 2025 denied Kalshi a preliminary injunction against the state's gaming regulators after they sent the company a cease-and-desist letter over its sports contracts. Maryland's district court was the first federal court in the country to side with a state on the sports event contract question.

Source: Reuters, via Q106 FM

The case, KalshiEX LLC v. Martin, No. 25-1892, was argued on May 7, 2026. The judgment itself was issued as a one-line per curiam order — "The judgment of the district court is AFFIRMED" — followed by two separate concurring opinions and a dissent, with each of the three judges reasoning differently. The Fourth Circuit is the third federal appeals court to side with a state against Kalshi.

Source: InGame

2-1Fourth Circuit vote to affirm the Maryland ruling
25-1892Case number, KalshiEX LLC v. Martin
Aug 2025Maryland district court first sided with a state on sports contracts
$710.1MBets taken by Maryland licensed sportsbooks in October

Two judges, two different reasons

Judge Roger Gregory's concurrence focused on preemption: whether the federal Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) displaces state gambling laws. Kalshi argued Congress had occupied the field by giving the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) "exclusive jurisdiction," and that Maryland's gaming laws conflict with the federal scheme. "I disagree with both arguments," Gregory wrote. He said the exclusive-jurisdiction language must be read together with the CEA's "special rule" for gaming contracts and the CFTC's Rule 40.11, and that because Kalshi's gaming contracts are self-certified rather than explicitly approved — and the CFTC has made no final determination requiring their removal — they are not traded in the sense the exclusive-jurisdiction grant requires. Gregory did not decide whether the contracts are "swaps."

Judge Stephanie Thacker's concurrence took the other route and did not use the word "preempt" at all. A swap, under the CEA, depends on the occurrence or non-occurrence of an event. Thacker concluded that Kalshi's sports contracts are not swaps because they do not condition payment on whether an event happens — they condition payment on the result of an event that everyone takes for granted will be played to completion. "Whether a prediction turns out to be right or wrong — and who gets paid — depends solely on the outcome of the completed sporting event," she wrote.

The dissent: "Swaps are swaps whether they are used to gamble"

Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin dissented from both colleagues. She wrote that the outcome of a sporting event — whether a team wins a game — is the occurrence of an event, that "swaps are swaps whether they are used to gamble," and that the CEA's special rule, which empowers the CFTC to prohibit gaming contracts it finds contrary to the public interest, shows Congress gave the CFTC authority over them. In her view the CEA preempts Maryland's law and the district court's ruling should have been vacated. She did agree that parlays and prop bets lack the financial consequences needed to count as swaps.

Kalshi's response

"Judges can't agree with each other on why we're wrong," a Kalshi spokesperson told InGame. "This splintered decision, including three separate contradictory opinions, demonstrates there is no unified coherent legal argument against prediction markets." Kalshi can ask the full Fourth Circuit to rehear the case en banc, or appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court.

The ruling adds to a genuine circuit split. The Third Circuit ruled 2-1 in Kalshi's favour. The Ninth Circuit held that state gambling laws are preempted for bona fide swaps but that sports contracts are not swaps, on different reasoning from Thacker's. The Sixth Circuit also produced a state-favouring outcome on yet another combination of reasoning. Former CFTC general counsel Rob Schwartz, quoted by InGame, called the Maryland decision "messy" and said that if the Supreme Court needed more reasons to intervene, this supplied them. New Jersey has already asked the Supreme Court to take up its appeal of the Third Circuit case; Kalshi's response in that matter is due December 7.

What happens next in Maryland

Maryland had agreed not to enforce its gambling laws against Kalshi while the Fourth Circuit decided the appeal. With the ruling now in, the state is free to pursue enforcement and may sue Kalshi in state court to have its sports contracts banned in Maryland. No Maryland ban is in place yet. The stakes are not abstract: Maryland's licensed sportsbooks took $710.1 million in bets in October and generated $13.8 million for the state, according to the Maryland Lottery and Gaming Control Agency figures cited in coverage of the ruling — revenue and consumer-protection rules that state regulators say unlicensed prediction markets bypass.

The other states in the Fourth Circuit — North Carolina, South Carolina, Virginia and West Virginia — now have a clearer path to act against sports contracts in their own courts. Nationally, Nevada, Michigan, Washington and, most recently, Louisiana have won injunctions banning sports contracts, forcing prediction markets to geofence those states, while the CFTC earlier this month warned exchanges that geofencing could violate its core principles. For Maryland users of Kalshi and rival platforms, the practical question is now timing: how quickly the state moves in court, and whether Kalshi seeks en banc or Supreme Court review before any ban takes effect.