A Michigan judge who has sat on the Warren bench for 30 years was convicted of drunk driving on Monday, November 16, after a bench trial heard how he rear-ended a stopped transit bus in Sterling Heights with a blood alcohol level more than twice the legal limit. Judge David Law of the 52-1 District Court in Novi found John Chmura, 63, guilty of operating while intoxicated, but not guilty of the more serious high-blood-alcohol charge, The Detroit News reported from the courtroom.
Source: The Detroit News
Chmura is a judge of the 37th District Court in Warren. He was appointed to that court in 1996, became its chief judge in 2008, and was reelected unopposed in 2024 to a six-year term. On Monday he stood as a defendant in another judge's courtroom, declined to comment after the verdict, and left with a sentencing date still to be set.
A split verdict after a 'battle of the experts'
The charge on which Chmura was acquitted — operating a motor vehicle with a blood alcohol content of 0.17 or more, Michigan's so-called 'super drunk' level — is a misdemeanour punishable by up to a year in jail. The lesser, included offence on which he was convicted, operating while intoxicated, carries a penalty of up to 93 days in jail. Judge Law said his decision came down to what he called a 'battle of the experts' over what Chmura's blood alcohol level actually was at the moment of the crash.
Michigan State Police forensic scientist Stephanie Grabowski testified that a blood draw taken a little over an hour after the crash measured Chmura's blood alcohol content at 0.196 — more than double Michigan's legal limit of 0.08 — with a margin of error of 0.018. A preliminary breath test at the scene had registered 0.16, and the police report recorded the later hospital blood test at 0.19.
Dr. Ronald Henson, a toxicology expert called by the defence, testified that a person's blood alcohol content can continue to rise even after they stop drinking, so Chmura's level could have been below 0.17 at the time of the crash and risen afterwards. Judge Law said that evidence left enough doubt that he could not convict on the high-blood-alcohol charge. 'There's no question the defendant had been drinking alcohol prior to operating this motor vehicle,' Law said. 'In this court's eyes, he wasn't dead drunk. He definitely had been drinking and definitely was under the influence.'
Source: The Detroit News
The night of the crash: a fundraiser, a stopped bus, and a body camera
The crash happened just before midnight on March 25, 2026, in Sterling Heights, where Chmura rear-ended a SMART bus near Van Dyke Avenue and Triangle Drive, according to earlier reporting by WDIV ClickOnDetroit. The bus was stopped when it was hit. Two people on the bus were treated at the scene for injuries, but no one was seriously injured.
Source: WDIV ClickOnDetroit
Sterling Heights Police Officer Johnathan Journeau, who questioned Chmura shortly after the crash and was one of the first witnesses to testify on Monday, told the court he knew immediately that alcohol was a factor. 'There was slurred speech and immediately a whiff, an odor of intoxicants,' Journeau said. 'It was a strong odor. It was something I almost immediately smelled.' His body-camera footage, played in the courtroom, showed Chmura telling the officer within seconds that he was a judge in Warren's 37th District Court, and saying he had been drinking at a fundraiser for a Macomb County Circuit Court judge hopeful and had drunk 'evidently too much.'
The footage and testimony described Chmura first refusing the roadside sobriety tests and a preliminary breath test — 'I don't want to do the tests, OK? Look, I've been on the bench for 30 years, I understand all of it, OK?' — then agreeing to attempt them. He struggled to follow the instructions, twice counted up instead of backwards, and, asked to recite the alphabet from C to N, started over several times and could not say what letter came after I. 'It's not OK. It's bad, it's bad,' he said during the tests. Journeau testified that Chmura was swaying and had to brace himself on his own car and on the officer, and that he arrested him because 'he had consumed too much alcohol to be operating a motor vehicle.'
Why the case was heard in Novi, by outside prosecutors
The trial sat in Judge Law's Novi courtroom because Sterling Heights' judges recused themselves from hearing the case. The prosecution was likewise handed to an outside office: because Chmura oversees cases brought by the Macomb County Prosecutor's Office, that office recused itself and the St. Clair County Prosecutor's Office handled the case. At his arraignment on June 10, 2026, Chmura's bond conditions required him to abstain from alcohol and controlled substances and to submit to alcohol monitoring twice a day, WDIV reported.
Chmura's attorney, David Kramer, told the court he did not deny that his client had too much to drink. He said the case went to trial because St. Clair County prosecutors refused to offer Chmura a plea deal, and he questioned whether Chmura was being held to a higher standard because he is a judge. St. Clair County Assistant Prosecutor Paul Soderberg declined to comment after the verdict; in closing arguments he had called the case one of 'incredibly dangerous driving as a result of operating with a high blood alcohol content.'
What happens next
A sentencing date will be set later. On the operating-while-intoxicated conviction, Chmura faces a penalty of up to 93 days in jail; the acquitted high-blood-alcohol charge, which carried up to a year, is now closed. The verdict makes a sitting Michigan district judge — one who has himself presided over drunk-driving cases in Warren for three decades — a convicted drunk driver, and the sentence handed down in Novi will be the next step in a case that has already travelled through three courts and two prosecutor's offices to reach a courtroom where no one involved owed him anything.
