WASHINGTON — Two Democratic senators demanded on Thursday that U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) suspend and withdraw a new asylum-interview rule they say punishes asylum seekers for the agency's own scheduling errors — even when applicants asked to reschedule in advance and the agency never replied.

Source: Office of Senator Edward J. Markey

Dec. 9, 2026Deadline for agency answers
Aug. 21, 2026Tougher rescheduling rule took effect
5Questions put to DHS and USCIS
2Senators behind the letter

Senators Edward J. Markey of Massachusetts and Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut sent the letter to Department of Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin and USCIS Director Joseph Edlow. It targets guidance USCIS posted online over the summer that requires asylum seekers to prove “exceptional circumstances” before they can get a new interview date.

“An immigration trap”

“U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services' new asylum-interview policy turns a scheduling problem into an immigration trap: an applicant who cannot prove abuse, serious illness, the death of an immediate family member, or similarly extraordinary harm may be denied a new interview date and then punished for not appearing, even when the applicant asked to reschedule in advance and USCIS failed to respond,” the senators wrote.

How the rule works

Under the new requirement, an asylum seeker who asks to move an interview for “exceptional circumstances” and is denied — or simply never hears back — can face punishment for missing the appointment, including being placed in removal proceedings. The senators warn that a missed appointment should not become “a backdoor route into removal proceedings.” According to the Asylum Seeker Advocacy Project, since August 21, rescheduling an asylum interview or biometrics appointment within 10 days of the date has required showing an exceptional reason.

The legal question

The senators question whether the policy is lawful under the Immigration and Nationality Act, and they asked USCIS to answer five questions by December 9: what legal authority the policy rests on; how it was developed and adopted; what factual record supports the change; how the agency handles a timely rescheduling request that is still undecided on the interview date; and what safeguards ensure applicants get fair notice and a meaningful chance to comply.

They also urged USCIS to “immediately suspend this policy, restore a fair rescheduling process, and bar adverse action while a timely request remains pending.”

Part of a wider pattern, senators say

The letter is part of a broader Democratic challenge to the administration's immigration changes. In August, Markey released a report titled “Under the Radar II: The Second Trump Administration's Stealth Attack on the U.S. Immigration System,” documenting lesser-known policy shifts. Bloomberg Law, reporting on the letter, said the policy risks more asylum denials because of the new requirements for excused absences and the agency's own pace in deciding rescheduling requests.

Why it matters

For asylum seekers — including many in immigrant and diaspora communities waiting months or years for an interview — the stakes are high. An interview date can arrive with little warning, and illness, a family emergency or a clash with work can make attendance impossible. Advocates say rescheduling used to turn on showing “good cause”; since August 21, applicants must clear the much higher bar of an “exceptional” reason. Under the new rule, the senators say, the same request can end with the case denied and the applicant facing deportation.

What happens next turns on the agencies' reply, due by December 9. If they suspend the policy, the dispute ends; if they defend it, the fight could move to Congress or the courts. This report draws on the senators' letter, Bloomberg Law and the Asylum Seeker Advocacy Project.