New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed Romanch's Law into law on Thursday, November 19, ending the city's horse-drawn carriage industry by June 1, 2028 — closing a trade that has operated on the streets of Manhattan for more than 150 years. Within hours of the signing, the carriage drivers' union filed a federal lawsuit seeking to stop the ban.
Under the law, no new carriage licences will be issued, and every existing licence expires on May 31, 2028. From June 1, 2028, horse-drawn carriages will no longer be allowed to operate on New York City streets, making New York the largest city in the United States to ban the industry.
The City Council approved the phase-out on October 22 by a vote of 40 to 7, with two members abstaining. This story covers what happened next — the mayor's signature and the lawsuit filed the same day. Read the earlier story
The teenager the law is named for
Romanch's Law is named for Romanch Mahajan, an 18-year-old tourist from India who died on June 17, 2026, after the horse pulling his carriage became startled and bolted in Central Park, throwing him from the carriage. His death, in the middle of the summer tourist season, turned a decades-long campaign against the carriages into a law within months.
The bill was sponsored by Council Member Christopher Marte of Manhattan. It was first known as Ryder's Law, named after Ryder, a carriage horse who collapsed on a Manhattan street in 2022. Mamdani signed the final version in the Blue Room at City Hall, flanked by Council Speaker Julie Menin and former Mayor Bill de Blasio. The Council had passed the bill on October 22, and the mayor had committed to signing it.
Drivers sue on the same day
On the same day the law was signed, the Transport Workers Union Local 100, which represents the carriage drivers, joined a medallion owner and two drivers in filing a federal class action in Manhattan. The case, Chiarello v. City of New York, No. 1:26-cv-10154, was filed in the US District Court for the Southern District of New York.
The lawsuit argues that the city is wiping out a licensed trade and leaving its owners holding medallions they can no longer sell, with no guarantee of payment. The drivers say the ban threatens their livelihoods and unfairly removes the value of the operating licences they hold. The case now goes to a federal judge, who will decide whether to pause parts of the law while the city drafts its transition plan.
What happens to the workers and the horses
About 200 people work in the industry as drivers and stable hands. The Mamdani administration says it will support them through medallion buybacks, career services and workforce development. City Hall will set up a Horse Carriage Worker Industry Program offering career advice, job training, entrepreneurship support, connections to employers, educational opportunities and tuition assistance.
The law also requires the administration to produce a transition plan for the industry by April 1, 2027. It orders the humane disposition of the carriage horses, barring their sale for slaughter or their transfer to another horse-drawn carriage business.
Why this matters beyond New York
For New York's Indian and South Asian communities, the story carries a particular weight: the law is named for an 18-year-old visitor from India, and its passage was driven by his family's loss. For the millions of tourists who visit Central Park each year, the carriages — a fixture of the park for generations — will keep running until the summer of 2028, then disappear from the streets.
What happens next
The federal lawsuit will now test whether the city can retire one of its oldest tourist traditions on schedule. The judge in Manhattan will first consider whether to freeze parts of the law while the case is heard. Separately, the administration must publish its worker transition plan by April 1, 2027, and the licences will wind down over the following year until the final carriages leave the streets on June 1, 2028.
Animal-welfare campaigners, who fought for decades to end the rides, call the signing a historic victory. The drivers and medallion owners say a licensed livelihood built over generations is being taken away without fair payment — and they are asking a federal court to decide.
