North Carolina Attorney General Jeff Jackson on Monday, November 16, asked a federal appeals court to rule that Uber can be held responsible when one of its drivers purposefully harms a passenger, filing a friend-of-the-court brief that urges the Fourth Circuit to uphold a jury verdict against the rideshare company in a 2019 Wake County case.
"Uber wants your business, but it doesn't want the responsibility of keeping passengers safe," Attorney General Jackson said in the announcement from Raleigh. "That's not how this works. We're asking the court to put passengers first." His office argues that the millions of North Carolinians who use rideshares need protection, and that Uber should be on the hook when drivers harm vulnerable riders.
The case underneath the brief
The appeal grows out of a lawsuit by a North Carolina passenger who accused an Uber driver of sexually assaulting her during a trip in Wake County in 2019. Trial reporting on the case describes a ride in Raleigh in March 2019 that ended just before 2 a.m., when the passenger alleged the driver grabbed her inner thigh as she arrived and asked if he could "keep it with him," prompting her to flee the vehicle. The driver denied the allegations, and the incident was not reported to law enforcement at the time; these remain the allegations on which the civil case was tried.
A jury in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of North Carolina found Uber liable and awarded the passenger $5,000 in damages in April 2026, after a trial that began on April 14. The award was small, but the legal ruling behind it was not: U.S. District Judge Charles R. Breyer held that Uber is a "common carrier" under North Carolina law — the same category as trains, buses and taxis — and therefore owes passengers a nondelegable duty of safe transport that it cannot hand off to its drivers.
What each side is arguing on appeal
Uber has appealed, arguing that it does not have a duty to protect the plaintiff from sexual assault by its drivers, and it has drawn support on appeal from the American Tort Reform Association and TechNet, which filed briefs backing the company. The passenger's lawyers, in a response brief filed on November 4, defend Judge Breyer's common-carrier ruling — a position summed up in legal coverage of the appeal as the argument that Uber is, in effect, a taxi company with an app.
Attorney General Jackson's brief lands on the passenger's side of that divide. He argues that Uber is responsible for the harms its drivers cause to passengers under North Carolina law, that common carriers are liable when their independent contractors harm passengers, and that while rideshare companies have modernised how people hail a ride, the service experience for the passenger is the same as a taxi. Not holding Uber responsible, he argues, would deny North Carolinians any meaningful remedy for sexual assaults or other intentional harms caused by rideshare drivers.
Common carriers — trains, buses, taxis — owe passengers a heightened, nondelegable duty of care built up over more than a century of law. If the Fourth Circuit agrees Uber belongs in that category in North Carolina, the company is liable when a driver assaults a passenger, even though drivers are classified as independent contractors.
A test case for thousands of claims
The North Carolina verdict was a bellwether — a test case — in federal multidistrict litigation that consolidates more than 3,300 similar claims by passengers who say rideshare drivers assaulted or harassed them. An earlier bellwether jury in Arizona this year awarded $8.5 million to a woman who said an Uber driver raped her when she was 19, and more than 500 additional cases are pending in California state court. What the Fourth Circuit decides about the common-carrier question will shape how those cases are valued and fought, which is why a state attorney general's intervention carries weight beyond one $5,000 verdict.
Uber's public position after the April verdict was that the small award — a fraction of what the plaintiff had sought — should bring the cases "back to reality," and the company noted the jury categorised the conduct as battery. The passenger's attorneys, for their part, have argued the verdict's importance lies in the liability rule it establishes, not the amount.
For Punjabi and other South Asian communities in the United States, the case cuts in two directions at once: rideshare and taxi driving is a major source of income for immigrant drivers in cities from Raleigh to New York and Fresno, and their families are also frequent passengers. A ruling that platforms carry a nondelegable duty would raise the safety obligations — and likely the insurance and screening costs — attached to every trip, whoever is behind the wheel.
Source: North Carolina Department of Justice — Attorney General Jeff Jackson announcement, Nov 16, 2026
What happens next
The Fourth Circuit, based in Richmond, Virginia, will now consider the appeal — docketed as No. 26-1640 — with briefs from both sides and their supporters on file. No decision date has been announced. Because this is the first federal appeals court to take up the common-carrier theory in the rideshare assault litigation, its ruling is expected to be watched by courts, platforms and plaintiffs' lawyers across the country, whatever the outcome.
