Two security guards who worked the door at Lucky's Bar & Grill in Cleveland's Old Brooklyn neighbourhood were indicted on Tuesday, November 17, after prosecutors accused them of repeatedly beating a man who was already on the ground outside the bar in July. The Cuyahoga County Prosecutor's Office announced that Michael Ramos, 37, and Alex R. Maldonado, 27, have each been indicted on one count of felonious assault. The announcement was posted by the prosecutor's office on Tuesday afternoon, and Cuyahoga County court records confirm an indictment entry dated November 17 in both men's cases.
Source: Cuyahoga County Prosecutor's Office announcement, Nov 17, 2026
The case goes back to Sunday, July 26, 2026. According to the prosecutor's office, at about 2:06 a.m. a 36-year-old man tried to enter Lucky's Bar & Grill on Memphis Avenue in Old Brooklyn — the Cleveland neighbourhood, not the separate city of Brooklyn, Ohio — and the two guards approached him outside. Prosecutors allege a physical confrontation followed in which the guards punched, kicked and stomped the man, and that the blows continued while he was down on the ground. These are the prosecution's allegations, not findings of guilt, and both men are presumed innocent unless proven guilty.
Prosecutors say the man lost consciousness and was treated for head, neck and facial injuries, including a cut at his right eyebrow. The prosecutor's announcement does not name the man; in the court records, the no-contact bond condition identifies the victim only by the initials J.R. The Cleveland Division of Police investigated the case, and the prosecution is being handled by the Cuyahoga County Prosecutor's Office, led by Prosecutor Michael C. O'Malley.
What the court records show
County court records list Maldonado as defendant A in case CR-26-716964-A and Ramos as defendant B in case CR-26-716964-B. Each case shows one indicted count of felonious assault under Ohio Revised Code section 2903.11(A)(1), the provision covering knowingly causing serious physical harm to another person — an offence the statute generally classifies as a second-degree felony. The complete indictment document has not been published in the online docket, so the full wording of the grand jury's charge has not been independently reviewed.
Source: Cuyahoga County Clerk of Courts case records CR-26-716964-A/B
Both cases were bound over and entered on October 27, 2026, after starting in Cleveland Municipal Court — case 2026CRA009554 for Maldonado and 2026CRA009555 for Ramos. The dockets show a personal bond of $0 set and posted on October 27 for each man, with a recorded condition that they have no contact with the victim. No plea, trial date or disposition appears in the records yet.
Arraignments — the hearings at which the men will formally hear the charge and enter pleas — are scheduled in the Common Pleas Arraignment Room on the 12th floor of the Justice Center in downtown Cleveland: Friday, December 4, 2026, at 8:30 a.m. for Ramos, and Monday, December 7, 2026, at 8:30 a.m. for Maldonado. Hearing schedules can change, and neither docket listed an attorney for either man when the records were reviewed on November 17, which does not by itself establish that either man lacks counsel.
The video, and the other side of the story
The July confrontation was captured on video that later circulated widely online. In September, News 5 Cleveland described a roughly four-minute recording near the bar's entrance and a separate 39-second bystander recording from across the street. Its report described the man striking a guard before being taken down, followed by blows from security personnel while he was on the ground — and cautioned that a short clip alone does not establish the entire sequence or resolve a claim of self-defence. Cleveland 19 (WOIO) published its own investigation of the incident on September 16 and also reported the indictment on November 17.
Source: News 5 Cleveland, September 2026 report
On the night itself, Cleveland 19 reported, police responded to a call about a man refusing to leave; someone involved had left before officers arrived, and the people who remained declined to make a report. The bar's owner, Frank White, previously argued publicly that the guards were defending themselves after the man struck a guard and made threats, and he alleged the man appeared intoxicated — a claim that has not been independently established. White also told News 5 in September that the staff involved were no longer employed at the bar. Those statements were made before the indictment and are not a response to it.
Why this case matters, and what happens next
The indictment is the first formal criminal charge in a case that has been argued over in Cleveland for nearly four months — first as a police call that produced no report, then as viral video, and now as a grand jury accusation that the force used by two private security guards crossed the line into a felony. An indictment is a formal accusation, not a conviction: a grand jury decides only that there is enough evidence to bring a charge, and the men will have the chance to plead, to challenge the prosecution's account — including any claim that they acted in self-defence — and to go to trial. What happens next is the December arraignments, followed by pretrial proceedings in Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court.
July 26, 2026, ~2:06 a.m. — confrontation outside Lucky's Bar & Grill, Memphis Avenue, Cleveland. September 2026 — video circulates; News 5 Cleveland and Cleveland 19 investigate. October 27, 2026 — cases bound over to county court; $0 personal bond with no-contact condition. November 17, 2026 — grand jury indictment announced. December 4 and 7, 2026 — arraignments at the Justice Center.
