DALLAS — A citizen campaign to keep Dallas City Hall in its landmark home cleared a major hurdle on Wednesday, when the Save Dallas City Hall Coalition delivered roughly 34,500 petition signatures to City Secretary Bilierae Johnson — far more than the roughly 20,000 valid signatures needed to put the building's future before voters in May 2027.

Source: CandysDirt

34,500Signatures delivered
20,000Valid signatures required
30 daysTime taken to collect them
May 2027Proposed vote date

Dozens of supporters gathered in the plaza in front of City Hall to greet coalition members, who arrived by minibus carrying the petitions. Among those delivering them were coalition leader Bruce Richardson and Zaida Basora, executive director of AIA Dallas, along with current and former city officials. Council Members Laura Cadena (District 6), Paula Blackmon (District 9), Cara Mendelsohn (District 12) and Paul Ridley (District 14) — all supporters of keeping City Hall operations at 1500 Marilla Street — turned out to show their support, as did former Mayor Laura Miller.

A procession then made its way to the city secretary's office on the fifth floor, where Johnson received the petition. Her office will now review the signatures in the coming weeks to verify that enough of them come from registered Dallas voters. The coalition collected considerably more than the required number, giving it a cushion in case some signatures are rejected — other local outlets put the total delivered at about 35,000.

“This was huge”

“This was huge. This was like Christmas,” said trial attorney Ben Abbott, the campaign's largest single donor. “It was really a people's movement.”

What the amendment would do

The proposed charter amendment would require voter approval before the city's primary municipal operations could be moved out of 1500 Marilla Street. If voters approve it, any future move would need another referendum — taking the decision out of the hands of the mayor and the 14 council members and giving it to the full electorate.

What happens next

If the city secretary certifies that at least 20,000 signatures are valid, the petition goes to the Dallas City Council, which is required by state law to put the proposed amendment on the ballot. Organisers expect the council to formally call the election sometime in February, with the vote itself in May 2027. The coalition gathered the signatures in just 30 days — half the 60 days allowed — according to organisers.

Why the building is at risk

The petition is the latest chapter in a nearly year-long fight over the future of the Brutalist landmark, designed by architect I.M. Pei and completed in 1978 as the centrepiece of former Mayor Erik Jonsson's civic vision. Jonsson's granddaughters carried the first batch of signatures into the building their grandfather helped create.

In June, the city council voted 9-6 to shelve a proposed phased repair strategy for the building while directing City Manager Kimberly Tolbert to continue exploring relocation and redevelopment. City-commissioned consultants have estimated that repairing and modernising the ageing building could cost more than $1 billion over two decades — a figure preservation advocates dispute, arguing officials have conflated essential repairs with extensive modernisation.

The consultants identified a leaking roof, failing emergency generators, deteriorating heating, ventilation and electrical systems, and water intrusion affecting the plaza and underground parking garage. But the building's concrete structure was deemed sound. “The building is viable as it is. It's not endangered,” Ridley said. “It is structurally solid, and with all of the engineers poring over this building, no one identified any structural faults.”

The controversy was fuelled by the Dallas Mavericks' reported interest in redeveloping 1500 Marilla Street for a new arena and entertainment district. The franchise has since shifted its attention to the former Valley View Center site in North Dallas, but downtown stakeholders have continued to call for City Hall to relocate anyway, to jumpstart redevelopment in the neighbourhood's southern sector.

A lawsuit running alongside the petition

The coalition is fighting on two fronts. In August it sued the city — naming the city, Mayor Eric Johnson, all 14 council members, Tolbert, Historic Preservation Officer Marcus Watson and Chief of Real Estate John Johnson — alleging that City Hall's disrepair amounts to “demolition by neglect” under Proposition S, a charter amendment voters passed in November 2024. On Monday, the city asked a judge to dismiss the suit, arguing Proposition S is unconstitutional and the coalition lacks standing; a ruling is expected before the end of the year. Tolbert declined to comment on the petition because of the pending litigation. Former Mayor Miller said she has begun independently examining the city's historical spending and deferred maintenance records to build a clearer picture of what preservation would actually cost. “If you're an elected official in Dallas and you see all these people cheering in the city secretary's office because we turned in the petitions, I would hope you'd think, ‘I need to listen to what my constituents want,’” Miller said. Mendelsohn was blunter: “No one would get elected or reelected mayor after voting against saving City Hall.”

This report draws on reporting by CandysDirt, The Dallas Focal and D Magazine.