Dallas officials are moving forward with an audit of the police department’s crime reporting after the city auditor confirmed that possible inaccuracies have been found in the data used to track violent crime. The City Council’s Finance Committee voted to keep the audit in place, and the review will ask directly whether the controls are strong enough to ensure the crime statistics reported to the FBI are accurate.
Source: The Dallas Focal — Dallas launches audit of violent crime data
What the auditor flagged
City Auditor Rory Galter told city leaders on Tuesday that the scope of the potential errors is not yet known, but that the city should examine the issue. The concern surfaced during an entrance conference with the Dallas Police Department, according to an email from Galter’s office. The audit language asks directly: “Are controls in place to ensure the crime statistics reported to the FBI are accurate?”
Council member Cara Mendelsohn said she wants the review to determine whether crimes are being downgraded or reclassified. “There is data to suggest there is an increase in a lower charge compared to a higher charge,” she said. The question matters because how an offence is classified decides whether it counts toward the city’s reported violent crime rate.
Police officials who spoke to the council on Thursday said the potential inaccuracies are limited in scope. Dallas Police Major Steve Bishop acknowledged that certain offences, such as aggravated robberies, have been downgraded — but he described the issue as not extensive.
Why the numbers matter
The review comes as Police Chief Daniel Comeaux has publicly touted a drop in violent crime in Dallas in recent months. If offences have been systematically recorded as lesser crimes, the claimed improvement may be overstated — and residents, businesses and policymakers would be judging the city’s safety on figures that do not reflect what officers actually encountered. FBI crime statistics also feed funding decisions, staffing debates and the national picture of violent crime.
Dallas has been here before
This is not the first time Dallas’s crime counting has faced scrutiny. In 2009, a Dallas Morning News investigation found that police were misreporting violent attacks — recording as simple assaults offences that federal guidelines said should have counted as aggravated assaults. Reporters examined one week’s worth of assault reports, more than 500 of them, and found only 75 had been classified as aggravated. About 40 of the rest should have been, under the guidelines — cases involving bottles, pipes, bats and bricks, attempted stranglings, a knife and a rifle.
The newspaper sent summaries to the Texas Department of Public Safety and to FBI experts, who agreed the cases were aggravated assaults. The review estimated the department’s tally of aggravated assaults should have been at least 50 percent higher. Aggravated assaults make up more than a third of a city’s reported violent crime, so a change in how they are counted moves the headline rate sharply.
Source: Poynter — Dallas Morning News misreporting investigation
What happens next
The audit is expected to be completed sometime during the city’s current fiscal year. Its scope is still being set, and the council will receive its findings. For now, nothing has been proven: the audit tests whether the controls work, not whether anyone deliberately altered the numbers. But the fact that the city’s own auditor raised the flag — and that the council chose to keep the audit rather than drop it — means the figures Dallas has been reporting to the FBI will now be checked line by line.
How many cases were reclassified, how far back any errors go, and whether the FBI figures will need to be corrected. Those are the questions the audit is meant to answer — and the answers will decide whether Dallas’s reported fall in violent crime survives scrutiny.
