The Dallas Independent School District Board of Trustees voted 6–3 on Thursday night to close six schools, a decision district officials say is necessary to help offset a $128 million budget shortfall driven by years of declining enrolment. The closures will take effect in the 2027–28 school year, and the vote drew emotional protests from parents and community leaders who said the closures fall hardest on Black and low-income neighbourhoods.
The six schools on the list
The schools slated for closure are J.J. Rhoads Learning Center, N.W. Harllee Early Childhood Center, Harrell Budd Elementary School, Ignacio Zaragoza Elementary School, Arlington Park Early Childhood Center and Boude Storey Middle School. Under the plan, Harrell Budd students will be split between Cedar Crest and John Neely Bryan elementary schools, Boude Storey students will move to Dr. Frederick Douglass Todd Sr. Middle School, J.J. Rhoads students will move to H.S. Thompson Elementary School, and Zaragoza students will move to William Lipscomb Elementary School. Arlington Park students have already moved to Obadiah Knight Elementary School.
Why J.J. Rhoads became the flashpoint
Much of the opposition focused on J.J. Rhoads, a stand-alone pre-K centre in South Dallas that also houses a resource centre offering a food pantry, counselling and English-language classes. The campus enrolled 119 students last week and operates near capacity because a large part of the building is devoted to the resource centre. According to meeting documents, the district loses $1.2 million a year operating the campus — the largest operating deficit of any school in the district. District officials have said the resource centre will remain open after the pre-K centre closes, and the district has said consolidation could save about $2.6 million per campus closed.
Trustee Ed Turner, who represents South Dallas, proposed voting on J.J. Rhoads separately from the other five campuses, but that motion failed 6–3. Turner said district leaders did not notify him that a campus in his district was being targeted, and that he learned J.J. Rhoads was included only after a parent told him. He also said he did not learn until Thursday night that the school was targeted because the district is phasing out stand-alone pre-K centres, not because of low enrolment. "The community wants to trust you, but they want a fair process," Turner said after the vote. Trustees Joyce Foreman and Byron Sanders joined Turner in voting against the plan. Foreman warned that repeated closures in Black communities could drive Black families out of the district, and pointed out that the three Black board members voted against the closures while the six white and Hispanic members supported them. "Don't tell us what our pain is," Foreman said. "We're telling you what our pain is."
A decade of shrinking enrolment
The budget gap stems in part from a decade of declining enrolment. Dallas ISD has about 18% fewer students this year than in the 2016–17 school year, and Texas public schools have lost more than 135,000 students for the 2026–27 school year — the largest single-year decline in state history, bigger even than the drop during the first year of the Covid-19 pandemic. Because Texas funds schools largely on average daily attendance, fewer students translate directly into less state revenue. The district had avoided broad school closures over the past five years, unlike other North Texas districts, as leaders waited to see whether enrolment trends would reverse. Superintendent Stephanie Elizalde told the Dallas Morning News editorial board this month that continued and projected declines left the district with no choice but to act.
Ratings risk at two campuses
Harrell Budd and Boude Storey have received D and F ratings for the past three years, placing the district at risk of state takeover if either school reaches five years of low ratings. Tiffany Huitt, the district's chief of schools, said the district is moving away from stand-alone pre-K centres after expanding pre-K at elementary schools, and that Zaragoza was targeted because of declining enrolment. Jacqueline Rivers Owens, a former Boude Storey principal, noted that all the schools slated for closure serve predominantly economically disadvantaged students — Boude Storey's student body was 98% economically disadvantaged last year. "Closing a building does not eliminate students' needs for effective teachers, tutoring, counselling, language services, special education, attendance support or transportation," she said. "Those needs will still require funding."
What happens next: the six closures take effect in the 2027–28 school year. District officials have not said what will happen to the closed buildings. The J.J. Rhoads resource centre — food pantry, counselling and English classes — will stay open. The same board meeting's agenda also included a $1.5 billion bond authorisation for school construction and refunding.
The meeting at the Dallas County Schools Technology & Training Center grew tense. Nearly two dozen parents, community members and supporters urged the board to find alternatives, and at least one attendee, Brandy Williams of South Dallas, was escorted out by police after shouting at board members. Diane Ragsdale, a former Dallas City Council member, reminded the board of the commitment it made to South Dallas in 2019 when J.J. Rhoads reopened as an early childhood school with an on-site resource centre. "We are not simply asking you to keep a school building open," Ragsdale said. "We're asking you to preserve an educational opportunity, to protect a vital community resource and to honor a promise made to the families of South Dallas." After the vote she said she was "grossly disappointed" and doubted the district could repair its relationship with the community anytime soon.
For Dallas's large immigrant and South Asian communities, the decision lands close to home. The Rhoads resource centre's English-language classes and food pantry serve exactly the families who rely most on a neighbourhood school, and the closures push hundreds of children — most of them from low-income households — into new campuses across the city. Trustee Lance Currie, who supported the plan, said he respected families' concerns but argued it moves the school's six classes to another campus rather than ending the programme, and that the $1.2 million saved could help more students across the district. Sanders said J.J. Rhoads sits in a part of South Dallas that has absorbed too many school closures in the past, and that keeping it open would have been an opportunity to do right by the community.
