A second federal judge has blocked construction of President Donald Trump's proposed 250-foot triumphal arch, saying during a hearing in Alexandria, Virginia, on Friday, November 20, that she would issue a preliminary injunction halting the project indefinitely while the legal challenge continues.

Source: Reuters

US District Judge Leonie Brinkema called the project a "rushed job" that lacked a legal basis. She said there were multiple defects in the federal government's analysis of the economic and environmental impact of the arch, including an inadequate explanation of how it would affect nearby Reagan Washington National Airport.

Source: Reuters

250 ftHeight of the proposed arch (76 metres)
2Federal judges who have now blocked the project
Dec 3Date through which the Washington judge's order runs

The case in Virginia

The challenge was brought by the County Board of Arlington County, Virginia, which sued in October. The case is County Board of Arlington County, Virginia v. National Park Service, No. 1:26-cv-03372, in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia. Brinkema, appointed by President Bill Clinton, said from the bench that she would grant the county's request to block construction while the case continues.

Source: Bloomberg Law

The 250-foot arch would be built in Memorial Circle, which is part of Washington, DC, but sits on the Virginia side of the Potomac River, a short distance from Arlington National Cemetery and Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport, both in Arlington.

Source: NPR

The first block

Earlier this month, Washington District Judge Tanya Chutkan temporarily blocked the administration from breaking ground, and on Wednesday she extended that order through December 3 while she considers a longer-term injunction. Read the earlier report

Two courts, one project

Brinkema is the second judge to rule against the arch this week — and the second judge overall to halt it. Chutkan, in the District of Columbia, has temporarily blocked the administration from moving forward with construction activities, following legal challenges filed by the attorneys general for Washington and Virginia and a group of Vietnam War veterans. She recently extended her order through December 3 while she considers a request to put construction on hold for the duration of the case.

Source: Bloomberg Law

Bloomberg Law reported that Brinkema's preliminary injunction would likely delay the project for months, as the president seeks to reshape Washington's historic landmarks. The Friday decision is the latest setback to that effort.

Source: Bloomberg Law

What an injunction means — and what it does not

A preliminary injunction is not a final ruling on whether the arch can ever be built. It is a court's decision that, on the evidence so far, the challengers are likely to succeed and that construction should not go ahead while the case is decided. The government can appeal, and the underlying case over the environmental and economic review will continue in both courts.

The airport question

One of the defects Brinkema pointed to was the government's explanation of the arch's impact on Reagan Washington National Airport, one of the busiest airports in the country, which sits just south of the proposed site across the Potomac.

What happens next

Brinkema is expected to issue the written injunction following Friday's hearing. Chutkan will decide in the coming weeks whether to extend her own block for the full duration of the case. If the administration appeals, the fight could move to the appeals courts — and the arch, which Trump wanted to see rising at Memorial Circle, now faces two separate court orders standing in its way.