The Delhi High Court has held that an Aadhaar card, by itself, is not proof of a person's date of birth, upholding a Labour Court award that found a woman worker's termination illegal.
Source: Live Law
Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri was hearing a petition by M/s J.J. Electronics against an award of Labour Court-IX, Rouse Avenue Courts, New Delhi, in LID No. 78/2018. The Labour Court had held that the services of Smt. Rosamma Joy were illegally terminated and awarded her full back wages.
The dispute over two dates
Joy, who worked as a "Finishing Man" and had been employed with the establishment since December 1981, was terminated on 20 May 2017, after she demanded revised minimum wages. The management said she had reached the superannuation age of 58, pointing to her Aadhaar card, which recorded her date of birth as 20 May 1959.
The Labour Court, however, relied on the record the management itself had furnished to the Employees' State Insurance Corporation (ESIC) when Joy was registered on 26 June 2010, which gave her date of birth as 20 May 1960. On that date, she had not yet reached superannuation, and her termination without complying with Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, was illegal.
The High Court agreed. It noted that the Aadhaar Act recognises Aadhaar as proof of identity, not of date of birth, and that the UIDAI records dates of birth on the basis of documents or self-declarations. It also relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Saroj v. IFFCO-Tokio General Insurance Co.
"An Aadhaar card is not, by itself, proof of date of birth," the court observed, adding that the Labour Court's preference for the ESIC record was a plausible view based on the evidence and could not be called perverse.
The court held that once the management had recorded Joy's date of birth as 1960, it could not later rely on a different date in an Aadhaar card to end her services a year earlier. It upheld the award of full back wages from 20 May 2017 to 20 May 2018, at Rs 14,698 a month, with consequential benefits and 6 per cent interest, and directed the company to pay within four weeks of the judgment.
The ruling matters beyond this one case: employers and workers across the country routinely treat Aadhaar as the final word on age, and the court has now made clear that where records conflict, their relative evidentiary value must be assessed — Aadhaar alone does not settle it.
