Earlier today: the Berlin summit outcome

European leaders agreed in Berlin that Europe must have a coordinated seat in the next round of talks with Russia, hours after the Trump–Putin–Xi summit in Shenzhen. Read the earlier story

French President Emmanuel Macron has urged Ukraine's allies to reopen the question of Ukraine joining NATO, saying the issue — set aside since Russia's full-scale invasion in 2022 — is now relevant to European security.

Source: Reuters

"Faced with the maximalist nature of the Russian position, I believe we need to reopen the question of Ukraine's accession to NATO," Mr Macron told reporters in Berlin on Thursday after a Coalition of the Willing summit, according to France 24, which credited its report to AFP.

Source: France 24 with AFP

Mr Macron also urged allies to do the "maximum" to deliver the air defence systems and interceptors Ukraine urgently needs, as Russian strikes keep hitting the country's power grid ahead of winter.

Source: Euronews

Why this matters now

Ukraine's NATO membership was effectively taken off the table in early 2022, when Western allies feared that admitting a country at war with Russia could trigger a direct NATO–Russia confrontation under the alliance's Article 5 mutual-defence clause.

The question returned to the agenda this month. President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said on 14 November that US negotiators had floated the idea of Ukraine withdrawing from the eastern Donbas region in exchange for NATO membership during US-mediated talks in Abu Dhabi — the first time the idea had been raised, he said.

The US floated the Donbas-for-NATO idea in Abu Dhabi — and Kyiv said it could go to a referendum. Read: Donbas for NATO?

Moscow has pushed back hard. Russia's Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov said on 17 November that Russia categorically rejects Ukraine joining NATO, while US Secretary of State Marco Rubio has privately called membership "unrealistic" in the short term, according to European officials.

40+countries and partners at the Berlin summit
€70bnNATO allies' military pledge for Ukraine in 2026 — yaani about $77bn

What Zelenskyy said

Asked about the NATO question in Berlin, President Zelenskyy said a real security guarantee for Ukraine would mean US or European "forces, bases" on Ukrainian territory, France 24 reported.

No immediate response from Moscow or from other NATO capitals to Mr Macron's call had been reported by Thursday evening.

What happens next

European, Ukrainian and American advisers were due to meet at the German Chancellery on Thursday evening to carry the Berlin discussions forward, and Chancellor Friedrich Merz has said fresh talks with Russia will take place soon. Whether Moscow accepts a European seat at the table — and whether NATO membership moves from a French proposal to an allied position — remains undecided.

What is solid

  • Macron called for reopening the question of Ukraine's NATO accession at the Berlin summit on 19 November.
  • The Coalition of the Willing met in Berlin on 19 November with more than 40 countries and partners.
  • Zelenskyy said on 14 November that US negotiators floated a Donbas-for-NATO idea in Abu Dhabi.

What is only claimed

  • Whether NATO allies will back reopening Ukraine's membership question.
  • Whether Russia will accept European participation in the next round of talks with Moscow.