This story follows our November 19 report on the first-ever Trump–Xi–Putin trilateral summit in Shenzhen and the four-point 'Declaration toward Peace' the three leaders signed. Finland's president has now revealed what was cut from the draft before they signed it. Read the earlier story
The United States had a paragraph on Ukraine removed from the draft declaration that Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin signed after their first-ever trilateral summit in Shenzhen, Finnish President Alexander Stubb has revealed.
Source: Meduza
"And the wording there was unsatisfactory, so the US deleted it. I think it was the right thing to do," Stubb told Finland's newspaper Helsingin Sanomat, describing details that emerged during closed-door talks before a meeting of the 'coalition of the willing' in Berlin on November 19. He said the initial draft of the 'Declaration toward Peace' contained a paragraph on Ukraine, but the final text signed by the three leaders makes no mention of the country.
The final declaration runs to four points: reforming the United Nations; increasing the production and supply of refined petroleum products and reaffirming stable energy flows; upholding state consent and the immunities of state officials, with the International Criminal Court told it must not abuse its jurisdiction; and reaffirming that a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought, with a dialogue promised on reducing nuclear risks. It names neither Ukraine, Iran nor North Korea.
Trump's phone call to Berlin
Stubb also recounted a phone call from Trump to the Berlin meeting, made from the US president's plane as he flew home from China. Trump told the European leaders the war in Ukraine should be ended so Europe could spend its money on other things — but, Stubb stressed, there was no instruction to stop supporting Ukraine.
Source: Bergen County Herald
According to Stubb, Trump also hinted that the Europeans should talk to Putin directly. "The fact is, there's only one person in Russia who decides matters of war and peace, and that's Vladimir Putin," Stubb quoted Trump as saying.
Why the omission matters
The omission had already drawn attention: the declaration says nothing about the biggest war in Europe, even though Ukraine was discussed at the Shenzhen meeting. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said Ukraine was not the central topic. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy called Putin's attempt to "redraw the world" with his Chinese and American counterparts a "failure."
The November 19 meeting in Shenzhen, on the sidelines of the APEC summit, was the first formal three-way summit of the leaders of the United States, China and Russia. Trump later told NBC News the meeting was "a 12" out of 10. Before the trilateral, Trump held separate meetings with Putin and Xi, and the three leaders' declaration was published in matching English texts by the White House, China's foreign ministry and the Kremlin.
The declaration promises a dialogue on nuclear risks but sets no date, venue or agenda — and the war it avoids naming goes on. In the same week, Russia fired more than 400 drones and 110 missiles at Ukraine in one of its largest barrages of the war, and Russian missiles came down in Poland. The coalition of the willing met in Berlin to discuss security guarantees for Kyiv, and no new peace talks have been scheduled.
