The Trump administration has filed a notice of appeal challenging an Alabama federal court’s order that certified a class of construction workers and barred immigration officials from entering private construction sites without warrants, detaining workers without justification, and continuing to hold them after they showed proof of lawful presence. The appeal, reported on Friday, sends the closely watched case to the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.

Source: Law360

The order under appeal comes from Chief U.S. District Judge Jeffrey U. Beaverstock of the Southern District of Alabama, in the class-action lawsuit Garcia Venegas v. Homan, filed on September 30, 2025. The case challenges a joint federal operation — the “Gulf of America Homeland Security Task Force” led by the Department of Homeland Security — that has raided construction sites across southern Alabama.

Source: Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse

The case: a U.S. citizen detained at his own job sites

The lead plaintiff is Leonardo Garcia Venegas, a U.S. citizen who builds homes in Baldwin County, Alabama. He says immigration officers detained him three times — twice before he filed suit, and once after — even though he showed a valid REAL ID, Alabama’s STAR ID, on every occasion. According to the complaint, officers wrestled him to the ground during one arrest and refused to release him on both occasions even after seeing his identification.

Source: Reason

Venegas sued senior federal officials, including the White House border czar, the Department of Homeland Security, the Department of Justice and the Attorney General, represented by the public-interest law firm the Institute for Justice. The lawsuit alleges the task force conducted dragnet raids on private construction sites, detained workers based on racial profiling rather than particularized suspicion, and refused to accept valid identification such as REAL ID-compliant driver’s licences as proof of citizenship.

Source: Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse

3Times Venegas says he was detained despite showing a valid REAL ID
13Counties in Alabama’s Southern District covered by the court’s order
September 21, 2026Date Judge Beaverstock stayed the three challenged policies
September 30, 2025Date the class-action lawsuit was filed

What the judge blocked on September 21

On September 21, 2026, Judge Beaverstock issued a temporary stay of all three challenged policies under the Administrative Procedure Act, finding Venegas was likely to succeed on the merits. The stay blocks: warrantless entry into the non-public areas of private construction sites without consent; preemptive detention of workers without reasonable suspicion that they are undocumented; and continued detention of workers after they produce evidence of citizenship or lawful presence.

Source: Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse

The government had argued that a construction site should be treated as an “open field” where officers are always permitted to enter without a warrant. Judge Beaverstock rejected that argument, finding that active, private workplaces — marked by fencing and “No Trespassing” signs and occupied by working crews — are not abandoned land. “The nature of the worksite does not open the floodgates to warrantless government intrusion and there exists no justification to enter a construction site that is not open to the public to conduct warrantless seizure,” he wrote.

Source: Reason

The judge found the warrantless-entry policy likely violated the Fourth Amendment and the federal regulation that bars immigration officers from entering the non-public areas of a business to question employees about immigration status without a warrant or consent. The court also found the detention policies likely violated the Fourth Amendment — including by denying Venegas “the presumption that he was lawfully present” when he presented his REAL ID.

Source: Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse

On the same day, the court conditionally certified three classes for the purpose of discovery — one for each challenged policy — and denied the government’s motion to dismiss the Administrative Procedure Act claims. The order addresses the first two of Venegas’s detentions and covers only the 13 counties of the Southern District of Alabama, but the Institute for Justice views it as a victory for construction workers well beyond the state.

Source: Engineering News-Record

The government’s next moves — and the appeal

On October 19, the government asked Judge Beaverstock to reconsider or clarify the stay and the conditional class certification, arguing that the stay functioned as a de facto preliminary injunction and that the class certification was vague. The government also asked the court to seal identifying information of ICE agents involved in the raids. As of early November, that motion remained pending.

Source: Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse

The notice of appeal filed this week challenges both the class certification and the order barring the three enforcement practices. The 11th Circuit will now decide whether the stay survives — a ruling that will shape how immigration officers may operate on private job sites across Alabama, Florida and Georgia, the three states in the circuit.

Source: Law360

Why it matters for workers

For construction and trucking workers — including many immigrants and diaspora workers across the South — the case tests a basic question: when a worker shows a valid government-issued ID, does the stop have to end? The September ruling said yes. The appeal asks the 11th Circuit to say otherwise.

Jared McClain, a senior attorney at the Institute for Justice, called the September order “a huge blow to [the department’s] lawless enforcement practices,” saying the government had argued in court that it did not need warrants to enter private construction sites and round up workers, and that it could not trust government-issued IDs.

Source: Engineering News-Record

What happens next: the 11th Circuit will hear the appeal, while the case continues in the district court. Venegas filed an amended complaint on October 13 that formalized claims under the Federal Tort Claims Act, sought certification of the classes and a permanent injunction, and continues to seek damages for the detentions he says he suffered.

Source: Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse