NEW ORLEANS — The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit ruled on Friday that the House of Representatives unconstitutionally passed a $1.7 trillion government funding bill in 2022 through a pandemic-era rule that let lawmakers vote by proxy instead of in person, in a closely divided 9–8 decision by the full court.
Source: Reuters
The New Orleans-based court voted 9–8 to uphold an injunction that outgoing Republican Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton secured, blocking enforcement of one provision of that spending package — the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, which gave pregnant workers stronger workplace protections. The case is State of Texas v. Blanche, 5th Cir. en banc, No. 24-10386.
What the court decided
Writing for the majority, Judge Cory Wilson — joined by Chief Judge Priscilla Richman Elrod and Judges Edith Jones, Jerry Smith, Don Willett, James Ho, Kyle Duncan, Kurt Engelhardt and Andrew Oldham — held that the Constitution's Quorum Clause requires a majority of House members to be physically present to pass legislation. “'Proxy presence' does not count,” Wilson wrote, adding that while the House has wide discretion over its own rules, “the Quorum Clause's constraints on congressional power cannot be circumvented by congressional fiat.”
The court said the text, context, original understanding and unbroken historical application of the Quorum Clause “all indicate that Members of Congress must be present for quorum purposes — as the Supreme Court expressly held over 125 years ago, and as Congress has done ever since the Founding.” The court also rejected the government's argument that the enrolled-bill rule — which treats a bill's passage as conclusive proof of its authenticity — barred the court from reviewing how the bill was passed.
But the relief the court granted is narrow. Although the ruling concerns how the entire $1.7 trillion Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 was passed, the injunction it affirmed only bars the Justice Department and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission from enforcing the pregnant-workers provision against Texas. U.S. District Judge James “Wes” Hendrix had ruled in Texas' favour in 2024, and the Fifth Circuit affirmed that judgment.
Judge James Graves Jr., an appointee of Democratic President Barack Obama, dissented, calling the ruling “illogical, inexplicable, and invalid.” He questioned how the court could hold that the whole statute was unconstitutionally passed yet limit its judgment to one small part of the multi-trillion-dollar bill: “There is no explanation offered to explain why, if the entirety of the statute was unconstitutionally passed, this court's judgment should be limited only to one small sliver of the multi-trillion dollar bill.”
Why the ruling reaches beyond Texas
The decision opens the door to new legal challenges against other laws enacted during former President Joe Biden's administration through proxy voting, and it is certain to be appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court. Any broader fallout will depend on whether other states or litigants bring their own challenges, and on how the Supreme Court treats the Quorum Clause question.
The ruling also arrives at a moment of political change in Texas. The challenge was brought by the office of the outgoing Republican attorney general, Ken Paxton. A Democrat has since won the Texas attorney general race, so Republicans will no longer control the office that generated the proxy-voting challenge when the new officeholder takes over in January.
The House adopted the proxy-voting rule during the COVID-19 pandemic, allowing members to record their presence by proxy for quorum purposes. The House used the rule when it passed the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 on a 225–201 vote, with 226 members voting by proxy. The bill was signed into law by President Joe Biden. The proxy rule was abandoned when Republicans took control of the House after the November 2022 elections.
The provision at the centre of the case, the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, requires employers to offer reasonable accommodations to pregnant employees. Texas challenged only that provision, and the injunction the courts have now upheld applies only to enforcement of that law against Texas — not to pregnant workers' protections in other states.
What happens next
The Justice Department is expected to appeal to the Supreme Court, which would have the final word on whether proxy voting can ever count toward a quorum. Until then, the ruling changes nothing about the rest of the 2023 spending law's programmes: the decision's practical effect is confined to the pregnant-workers provision as enforced against Texas, while the constitutional question it raises — whether hundreds of members voting from elsewhere can make a quorum — now heads toward the highest court in the country.
