A federal appeals court has temporarily blocked the U.S. Army from detonating nearly five tons of unstable lead azide at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant in Middletown, Iowa, after environmental groups went to court to stop a blast that could scatter toxic lead dust across southeastern Iowa and into Illinois.

Source: Associated Press

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit issued a one-sentence administrative stay at 9:04 p.m. on Thursday, November 19, freezing the emergency permit the Environmental Protection Agency issued for the operation. The stay lasts until the court rules on the groups' emergency motion for a longer halt — which means the detonation the Army rescheduled for Monday, November 23, cannot go ahead unless the judges rule first.

Source: Associated Press

Earlier: Army postpones detonation to Monday

Awaaz Punjab reported on Thursday that the Army had pushed the planned Friday blast to Monday, November 23, after Iowa's governor, senators and environmental groups pressed for a delay. That plan has now been overtaken by the court. Read the earlier report

What the court ordered

The order, in full, reads: “An administrative stay of the emergency permit issued by the Environmental Protection Agency is granted until the emergency motion for stay is ruled upon by this court.” It was issued hours after the Iowa Environmental Council and the Sierra Club Iowa Chapter filed their emergency motion, and hours after the Army announced it was postponing the blast from Friday to Monday.

Source: Associated Press

“The Army can't detonate under the permit while the permit is stayed,” Thien Chau, an attorney with Earthjustice representing the two groups, told the Associated Press. The stay does not decide the case — it pauses the permit while the court weighs whether to block the detonation for longer.

Source: Associated Press

Who sued — and why

Earthjustice filed the suit on Thursday on behalf of the Iowa Environmental Council and the Sierra Club Iowa Chapter, challenging the EPA's emergency permit of November 13 under the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act, the federal hazardous-waste law. The groups argue the EPA approved the permit without adequately considering the health and environmental consequences, without fully evaluating safer alternatives, and without giving the public adequate notice.

Source: Iowa Starting Line

The groups say there is a safer way to deal with the material. Wally Taylor, legal chair for the Sierra Club Iowa Chapter, said the explosive could be destroyed by chemical neutralisation instead of detonation, and has argued the blast “should be canceled outright, not merely delayed.”

Source: Dubuque In Pursuit News

The race against the weather

The Army has warned that waiting carries its own danger. Acting Secretary of the Army Adam Telle, announcing the postponement on Thursday, called Monday “the latest possible moment prior to a forecasted temperature drop, which would risk further destabilization of the material.” Lead azide becomes more volatile in colder temperatures, and the Army says the 68 barrels — about 9,500 pounds, which the Army puts at 9,700 pounds — have been crystallising in storage for more than 20 years, making them too sensitive to move.

Source: U.S. Army

68barrels of degrading lead azide
9,700 lbof explosive to be destroyed
100 milesmodelled reach of the lead-dust plume
~400people live in Middletown

What happens next

The EPA has said it will respond to the court by Sunday, November 22, and lawyers for the environmental groups expect a ruling before Monday — but the court has set no date and has not said whether it will hold a hearing. If the court lifts the stay in time, the Army says it will still aim for Monday. The longer case runs much further: the EPA has until December 29 to hand over the full record behind the permit, and the groups have until January 12 to file their legal arguments.

Source: WHO 13 / KCAU 9

The bottom line

No detonation can happen under the EPA permit while the stay is in place. Monday was the Army's last safe date before colder weather makes the unstable explosive more dangerous — so the court's timing now matters as much as its decision.

Background: how the blast plan got here

Army staff found the degrading lead azide in bunkers at the plant in March. The chemical, used to make primers for munitions, had been held for 20 years in underground concrete tanks in a water-ethanol solution; checks found the tanks too dry and the material crystallising, leaving controlled detonation in place as the Army's chosen way to destroy it. The EPA issued the emergency permit on November 13, with air monitoring, environmental sampling and cleanup conditions. The plant, near the Iowa–Illinois border about 160 miles southeast of Des Moines, makes medium- and large-calibre munitions for the Department of Defense, and the Army says it will use buried concrete magazines, two-storey Hesco and sand barriers, soil saturation, air misting and perimeter air monitors to limit how much material leaves the site.

Source: Associated Press

The Army's own advisory warned the blasts would produce “an air plume with some lead-containing particles which will disperse in the air and deposit on the ground,” with modelling suggesting the plume could travel up to 100 miles, reaching communities in Illinois. Residents near Middletown City Park and Butterfly Park were asked to leave the area temporarily for several hours around the blasts, because vibrations could break windows, and people across the area were told to stay indoors, keep windows and doors closed, bring pets and livestock inside, and clean cars, windowsills and outdoor surfaces afterwards. Several school districts, including Burlington Community School District, had planned to close on Friday; with the postponement — and now the court stay — they will decide their Monday plans in light of what the court does.

Source: Associated Press

For truckers and travellers, the plant sits in the southeastern Iowa corridor near the Mississippi River crossings into Illinois, and the modelled plume area reaches toward the Illinois border. Anyone travelling through the region on Monday should check official Army and county advisories before the detonation window — and now, whether the court has allowed the blast to go ahead at all.

Awaaz Punjab first reported the Army's plan to detonate the degrading explosive on Friday, and the warnings that a lead-dust plume could drift 100 miles into Illinois. Read the first report