A federal judge in Brooklyn on Friday denied a request to free Oscar Belgal, the 28-year-old Dominican man who was shot and wounded by immigration officers during an arrest in New York last month, ruling that a possible procedural error in his case does not require his release from custody.
Source: Associated Press
U.S. District Judge Hector Gonzalez, of the Eastern District of New York, said in a written ruling that agents may have made a procedural error in serving an arrest warrant on Belgal before he was given a notice to appear in immigration court. But that was merely a technical error, he wrote, and it does not require Belgal to be released from federal custody while deportation proceedings continue.
What happened on October 8 in Marble Hill
On October 8, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents found Belgal as he was driving his five-year-old son home from school in the Marble Hill neighbourhood of Manhattan. Security camera footage released by the New York City police shows an officer in plain clothes running up to the car with his gun pointed at Belgal, then using the barrel of the gun to bash the driver's side window. A second officer then draws his gun as Belgal pulls away. The chase ends moments later, with Belgal's bullet-riddled car coming to rest.
Belgal was struck in the shoulder and neck. His son was not injured. His lawyers said he did not learn the men were ICE officers until he woke up later in hospital. According to reports of the incident, an agent fired seven rounds, and a bullet lodged in Belgal's neck below his left ear. As of October 23, the bullet was still in his body, according to the Legal Aid Society.
Two accounts of what happened
Federal officials maintained that ICE officers fired their weapons because they believed their lives were in danger. They said Belgal smashed his car into two government vehicles and "accelerated toward other officers."
Belgal's lawyers gave a different account. They said the agents did not have a valid warrant and never identified themselves before running up to Belgal's car, smashing a window and firing several shots inside. They also argued that his due process rights were violated because he was subjected to an "unreasonable use of extreme force" during his arrest.
"It is unconscionable that Mr. Belgal should have to endure another day in detention, separated from his family, particularly given everything he has already suffered."
Who is Oscar Belgal
Belgal, a 28-year-old Dominican national, entered the United States without legal authorisation in 2021, according to the Associated Press. About two years later he was arrested on robbery and other charges and eventually pleaded guilty to grand larceny. He was given a sentence of probation. In 2025 he was arrested again, this time on allegations that he attempted to sell controlled substances. That case remains pending.
The shooting took place during Operation Salvo, an ICE operation in New York City targeting the Trinitarios gang, to whom Belgal was allegedly connected. The allegation has not been tested in court in this case.
An earlier ruling — and what happens next
This was not the first time a judge had refused to free Belgal. On October 26, the same judge denied a request for his medical release, saying he had "received necessary and appropriate care and his medical condition is stable." Belgal remains held at the Metropolitan Detention Center in Brooklyn.
Judge Gonzalez noted that Belgal can still ask the immigration court to release him on bond. He also ruled that the petition Belgal filed for release from custody was not an appropriate venue for arguing that the agents used excessive force — that claim, he said, must be raised elsewhere. His deportation proceedings continue.
On October 26, the same judge denied Belgal's request for medical release, saying his condition was stable. Read the earlier story
