The state of Ohio has agreed to pay $10.2 million in settlements to five men who spent decades in prison for a 1992 killing in Toledo that they did not commit, according to court filings reported this week by WTOL 11 and WTVG 13 Action News. In filings dated Monday, November 16, a Lucas County Common Pleas Court judge declared all five men 'wrongfully imprisoned individuals' under Ohio law, clearing the way for the state to compensate them.
Source: Fostoria Free Press
Under the proposed agreements, Eric Misch, Louis 'Louie' Costilla Jr. and Joseph Rickard would each receive $2.9 million — $8.7 million combined. Brothers Ismael 'Mel' Vasquez and Lorenzo Vasquez would each receive $750,000. The five men were convicted in the 1992 killing of Vernon Huggins in Toledo's Wilson Park, and their convictions were later thrown out.
Settlements still need state approval
The money is not yet final. The settlement agreements are not binding until they are approved by the Ohio attorney general, the Ohio Court of Claims and the Ohio Controlling Board, according to the filings. Court documents reviewed by 13 Action News say the Vasquez brothers' $750,000 settlements must still be approved by the Ohio attorney general. Until those approvals come through, no money will be paid.
How the convictions fell apart
Judge Joseph McNamara vacated the convictions of Rickard, Costilla and the Vasquez brothers in December 2024, and all charges against them were dismissed on January 3, 2025. The five men had been convicted in the killing of Vernon Huggins, who died in Wilson Park in 1992. More than three decades after the crime, the courts have now formally recognised all five as wrongfully imprisoned.
The human cost is measured in decades. Ismael Vasquez spent 32 years in prison in connection with the Huggins murder, and his older brother Lorenzo Vasquez spent 22 years, according to WTVG. The other three men also spent years behind bars before their convictions were vacated — time that no settlement can give back.
How Ohio pays for wrongful imprisonment
Ohio law allows people declared wrongfully imprisoned by a court to seek compensation from the state. Once a court makes that declaration, the settlement goes through the Court of Claims, which handles claims against the state, and the Controlling Board, which must approve the payment. The same process has been used in other wrongful-imprisonment cases in Ohio, where the state has paid settlements after courts found people were wrongly convicted.
The settlements now go to the Ohio attorney general, the Court of Claims and the Controlling Board for approval. If approved, the $10.2 million will be paid out — $2.9 million each to Misch, Costilla and Rickard, and $750,000 each to the Vasquez brothers.
The reporting draws on the National Registry of Exonerations, which tracks wrongful convictions across the United States. For the five Toledo men, the November 16 court declaration closes a legal fight that began with a 1992 killing in Wilson Park and ended, more than 30 years later, with the state agreeing that they should never have been imprisoned at all.
Source: WTVG 13 Action News
