A South Carolina parole board voted unanimously on Thursday, November 19, 2026, to deny parole to Susan Smith, the woman convicted of killing her two young sons in 1994. Smith, 55, remains in prison at the Leath Correctional Institution in Greenwood County, where she is serving life sentences. It was her second parole denial in two years.
Smith appeared before the state's Board of Probation, Parole and Pardon Services by video from prison. She needed the support of at least two-thirds of the seven-member board to be released. Her former husband David Smith, the father of the two boys, testified against her release, telling the board that freeing her would be an injustice to his sons. Speaking for her release were her attorney, a forensic psychologist and her brothers. Smith told the board she had changed and matured since the killings.
The 1994 case
On October 25, 1994, in Union, South Carolina, Smith first told police that a stranger had taken her car with her two sons inside. She later admitted that the car had rolled into John D. Long Lake in Union County with the boys — aged 3 and 14 months — still strapped in their car seats. Both boys drowned.
Smith was convicted of murder in 1995. The jury that convicted her chose life in prison rather than the death penalty, and she was given two concurrent life sentences.
Why the board said no — and the first denial
Smith became eligible for parole after serving 30 years, under the sentencing law in effect at the time of her conviction. Her first request was denied unanimously on November 20, 2024, with the board citing the seriousness of the crimes and her unfavourable prison record. Under South Carolina law, a prisoner who is denied parole in her position can ask again every two years.
Parole is rarely granted in cases like this one. The board granted parole in only about 4% of the cases before it, and most of those were non-violent cases, according to the agency's own statistics. In Smith's case, the victims' family also opposed her release, as it did in 2024.
What is solid
- Smith was convicted of murder in 1995 and sentenced to life in prison.
- The parole board denied her release unanimously in 2024, and again unanimously on November 19, 2026.
What is only claimed
- Smith told the board she has changed and matured since the killings.
- Her lawyers argued she suffered a mental breakdown at the time of the crime.
- Her former husband says she has never shown remorse for killing their sons.
What happens next
Smith remains incarcerated at Leath Correctional Institution, and her convictions and life sentences stand. A parole grant would have meant conditional release under supervision, not an overturning of her convictions. She will be eligible to ask the parole board again in two years, in 2028, under the same review cycle.
The case remains one of the most notorious in American criminal history, and every parole review draws national attention. The board's unanimous vote on Thursday means one of the country's most closely watched prisoners stays behind bars — for now, the next decision point is 2028.
The board announced its decision on Thursday after hearing from Smith, her supporters and her former husband. No further hearing is scheduled until her next eligibility date.
