Earlier development

On Wednesday Israeli tanks crossed Gaza's 'Yellow Line' in the first ground operation beyond the ceasefire line since the October 2025 truce, in an operation Israel said was aimed at destroying a tunnel. Hamas called it a flagrant violation of the ceasefire. Read the earlier story

One year after the UN Security Council endorsed the Trump administration's 20-point plan to end the war in Gaza, five leading humanitarian organisations have given it a failing grade: 4 points out of 26. The scorecard was released on Thursday by the Danish Refugee Council, the Norwegian Refugee Council, Oxfam, Refugees International and Save the Children.

Source: Islamic Relief

The score is worse than the 5 out of 26 the same groups gave the plan at the six-month mark in April 2026. It grades the plan against its own stated objectives — civilian protection, humanitarian access, reconstruction and economic development, and freedom of movement and return.

4 / 26overall score one year on — down from 5 at the six-month mark
0score for humanitarian access — the same as in April
1,650Palestinians killed since the ceasefire began, with 5,975 wounded
49UN-coordinated aid trucks a day in September, against a promised minimum of 600

Humanitarian access scored zero, as it did in April. The plan, endorsed by Security Council Resolution 2803 on 17 November 2025, requires a minimum of 600 UN-coordinated aid trucks to enter Gaza every day. The scorecard found that fewer than 100 a day were getting in, and an average of just 49 a day in September. Shelter materials, medical equipment and supplies to restore water and sanitation remain blocked, the groups said, while nearly all of Gaza's 2.1 million people struggle for clean water, healthcare and enough food.

At least 1,650 Palestinians have been killed and 5,975 wounded since the ceasefire was declared in October 2025, according to Gaza's health authorities — more than double the death toll at the six-month mark. The United Nations considers the health ministry's figures reliable. Israeli forces now control 65 percent of Gaza, according to the UN humanitarian office OCHA, up from 58 percent when the ceasefire began; Islamic Relief put the figure at up to 70 percent.

'Displacement by design'

Al Jazeera, reporting the scorecard, described the plan's record as 'displacement by design'. The groups say the plan explicitly barred territorial occupation and required Israeli forces to withdraw — yet the 'Yellow Line' marking Israel's positions has moved further west, and this week's ground operation pushed tanks onto the main Salah al-Din road near the Nuseirat and Bureij refugee camps, with new evacuation orders for Palestinians in the area.

Source: Al Jazeera, via Barbados Gazette

Gaza's civil defence agency said three people were killed on Wednesday in separate strikes, and more than 5,200 people fled as armoured vehicles advanced. Hamas condemned the advance as a violation of the ceasefire; Israel said the operation was limited to destroying a tunnel it called an immediate threat to its troops, and said its forces were acting in line with the agreement.

On reconstruction, the scorecard notes that the US-backed Board of Peace unveiled a 2.45-billion-dollar Gaza Recovery Program in late September — yaani 2 arab 45 crore dollar — covering 66 projects over six months. But the National Committee for the Administration of Gaza, the body meant to run it, has still not been allowed to enter Gaza, and a 15-point implementation roadmap put to the Security Council in May was rejected by the Government of Israel.

What is solid

  • The scorecard gives the plan 4 of 26 points, down from 5 in April 2026
  • The plan requires a minimum of 600 UN-coordinated aid trucks a day; the scorecard records an average of 49 a day in September
  • At least 1,650 Palestinians have been killed since the ceasefire began, Gaza health authorities say

What is only claimed

  • Whether Israel has met its aid obligations — Israel's COGAT says it has met or exceeded them, while Gaza's Government Media Office says only 33% of the agreed trucks have entered
  • Whether the Yellow Line operation breaches the ceasefire — Hamas calls it a flagrant violation; Israel says its forces acted within the agreement

The Board of Peace, the body overseeing the truce, warned the Security Council earlier this week that the ceasefire could collapse without full implementation, blaming both sides for failing to meet their commitments. It is due to brief the Council again later this month. Save the Children chief Inger Ashing and Danish Refugee Council executive Lilu Thapa were among the aid leaders behind the scorecard.

What happens next turns on whether the truce holds through the winter. With the Yellow Line operation still under way, aid at a fraction of the promised level and 1.7 million people displaced, the agencies say the plan's second year will be judged by the same measures as its first: trucks getting in, people able to return home, and the killing stopping.