The International Commission of Jurists (ICJ) has concluded that Pakistan's highest courts have effectively been captured by the country's political branches, after two constitutional amendments stripped away the guarantees that kept the judiciary independent.
Source: International Commission of Jurists
In a report published on November 18, titled "Judicial Capture: Independence of the Judiciary in Pakistan after the 26th and 27th Constitutional Amendments", the Geneva-based body says the changes have "gravely impaired" the courts' ability to act as a check on the government and to give victims of human rights violations an effective remedy.
What the two amendments changed
The 26th Amendment, passed in October 2024, reshaped the Judicial Commission — the body that selects judges — so that judges no longer held a majority, and created constitutional benches inside the Supreme Court.
The 27th Amendment, passed in November 2025, went further: it turned those benches into a separate Federal Constitutional Court and moved constitutional cases out of the Supreme Court altogether. It also reshaped parts of the military command structure and expanded protections for government officials.
Two of the Supreme Court's most senior judges, Syed Mansoor Ali Shah and Athar Minallah, resigned in protest on November 13, 2025, the day the 27th Amendment became law. In its first year, the new Federal Constitutional Court decided 8,735 cases and received 6,657 new ones, according to figures cited in coverage of the report.
What the ICJ found
The ICJ says the cumulative effect of the amendments, and the way they were implemented, is that Pakistan's highest courts no longer enjoy the institutional guarantees of independence required by Article 14 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and the UN Basic Principles on the Independence of the Judiciary. Pakistan is a party to the ICCPR, and the report says the changes have impaired victims' right to an effective remedy under Article 2(3) of the treaty.
"The 26th and 27th amendments have done exactly what we feared: they have placed Pakistan's highest courts under the control of the executive. When the courts are captured, no one is left to hold the government to account, and victims of human rights violations have nowhere to turn."
The other side of the argument
The ICJ itself notes that Pakistan's judiciary needed reform — judges were appointed without transparency, and at times the courts overstepped into the domain of other institutions. The government has defended the amendments as a way to curb judicial overreach, reduce case backlogs and limit the politicisation of the Supreme Court. Canton argues none of those problems were fixed, and that public frustration with the courts was instead used as a pretext to bring them under the executive's control.
What is solid
- The ICJ published its report on November 18, 2026
- The 26th Amendment passed in October 2024; the 27th in November 2025
- Justices Mansoor Ali Shah and Athar Minallah resigned on November 13, 2025
What is only claimed
- Whether the amendments amount to 'judicial capture' — that is the ICJ's characterisation
- The government says the changes were needed to curb judicial overreach and cut backlogs
What happens next
The ICJ is calling for substantial constitutional and statutory changes, including revising or repealing provisions in both amendments that conflict with international law, clearer published criteria for judicial appointments, transparent reasons for each selection, and protections against transferring high court judges without their consent. The Human Rights Commission of Pakistan has separately called for both amendments to be reviewed. The ICJ's announcement records no response from the Pakistani government.
