The Supreme Court on Friday declined to urgently list an application seeking recall of a two-judge bench decision that referred petitions challenging the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023, to a Constitution Bench.

Source: Live Law

Advocate Prashant Bhushan mentioned the application before a bench headed by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, asking that it be placed before the same two-judge bench — Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma — which passed the order of reference.

Source: Verdictum

The recall application alleges that Justice Sharma had a conflict of interest because his son was appearing as counsel for the Election Commission of India. The court has not decided that allegation, and no finding on it has been recorded.

Source: Live Law

Why the plea sought urgent listing

Bhushan told the court that Justice Sharma is due to retire by the end of next week, and urged that the recall application be listed before the original bench next week so the question could be considered while the judge is still in office.

Source: Live Law

Chief Justice Surya Kant said Bhushan could raise the issue before the five-judge Constitution Bench when the matter comes up for hearing. Justice Joymalya Bagchi, who was also on the bench, observed that the Constitution Bench could consider the validity of the reference itself. The bench said the recall application would be listed before the same bench, and a judicial order would follow.

Source: Live Law

The split verdict behind the recall plea

In September 2026, the two-judge bench delivered a split verdict on the challenge to the 2023 Act. Justice Datta held that the challenge could be decided by applying settled constitutional principles without referring the matter to a larger bench, while Justice Sharma favoured referring the substantial constitutional questions to a five-judge bench.

Source: Verdictum

During Friday's hearing, the Chief Justice observed that Justice Datta had also ultimately agreed to refer the matter. Bhushan replied that the reference itself arose because of Justice Sharma's view.

Source: Live Law

What the 2023 law changed

The 2023 Act replaced the Chief Justice of India on the panel that selects the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners with a Union Minister nominated by the Prime Minister. It followed a March 2023 Supreme Court ruling that the selection panel should comprise the Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha and the Chief Justice of India. Petitions challenging the Act remain pending before the court.

Source: LawStreet Journal

September 2026split verdict by the two-judge bench
5 judgesstrength of the Constitution Bench the case was referred to
2023year of the Election Commissioners appointment law

What happens next: the recall application will come up before the same two-judge bench, and the Constitution Bench will take up the challenge to the 2023 Act, where the conflict-of-interest question can also be raised.