The Supreme Court on Friday directed its Secretary General to conduct a fact-finding inquiry into why an appeal filed by the Enforcement Directorate (ED) in 2023 against the grant of anticipatory bail to businessman Raman Singhal, also known as Raman Singla, was never listed for an effective hearing for nearly three years despite repeated judicial directions.

Source: Live Law

A bench of Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana was hearing the ED's challenge to a January 30, 2023 order of the Punjab and Haryana High Court granting Singhal anticipatory bail in a money-laundering case. The Chief Justice asked at the outset: “Why has this matter not been listed? September 2023, September 2024, September 2025, September 2026. This is what I want to know.”

Justice Bagchi described the lapse as “institutional lethargy”. When a lawyer suggested the delay may have been because benches were unavailable, the Chief Justice replied: “All benches were available.”

Three years without a hearing

The ED approached the Supreme Court in May 2023. The court issued notice on the appeal in September 2023 and passed repeated orders directing that the matter be listed again, including for final hearing or disposal. Yet the appeal remained without an effective hearing for nearly three years.

Source: Law Trend

The bench said the Secretary General must explain why the matter was not listed in terms of the court's order of July 2023 and after January 2024. Its order recorded that the matter “would not have been listed even today but for the latest administrative order”.

The case behind the delay

The underlying case concerns an alleged bank fraud of ₹155.21 crore involving Mahesh Timbers Private Limited. The ED alleges the company fraudulently enhanced Foreign Letters of Credit and diverted the proceeds to Amazon Exports Pte Ltd, a Singapore-based company of which Singhal was a director. The allegations have not been proved in court and remain the agency's case.

Senior Advocate Siddharth Dave, appearing for Singhal, told the court such a situation should not occur in the Supreme Court and that the Registry “can't be managed like that”. Senior Advocate Zoheb Hossain, for the ED, responded that the listing may not have happened because benches changed.

Bail left untouched

The bench disposed of the ED's appeal without interfering with the anticipatory bail, noting that the trial had already begun and eight prosecution witnesses had been examined. The court clarified that the High Court's bail order would neither serve as a precedent nor influence the outcome of the ongoing trial.

The court will take up the Secretary General's report when it is filed. The episode puts the spotlight on listing practices inside the country's top court, where a case can wait years for a hearing even after judges have ordered it to be listed.

Nearly 3 yearswithout an effective hearing
8prosecution witnesses already examined
₹155.21 crorealleged bank fraud at the centre of the case