Prayagraj — The Allahabad High Court has held that police cannot open a history sheet against a citizen without giving the person an opportunity to object, and directed the Uttar Pradesh government to frame guidelines to that effect. The court also ordered an annual review of history sheets so that entries against people later acquitted or exonerated are closed.

Source: LiveLaw

A Division Bench of Justice Siddharth and Justice Vinai Kumar Dwivedi passed the directions in an order delivered on November 17, while allowing a petition by Rais Ahmad of Chandausi in Moradabad district. The court quashed the Class-A history sheet maintained against him and directed that police surveillance of him be stopped at once.

Ahmad had been implicated in several criminal cases in 2005 under the Indian Penal Code, the Arms Act and the Uttar Pradesh Gangsters Act, but was acquitted in all of them and had faced no criminal case for nearly two decades. Police had nonetheless kept a history sheet against him and made frequent domiciliary visits to his home.

Colonial-era rules, no hearing

The court observed that the procedure under the Uttar Pradesh Police Regulations, framed during the colonial era, did not incorporate the principles of natural justice and could expose citizens to surveillance without a chance to contest the police report. It held that such surveillance without safeguards does not meet the standards of Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution.

Under the court's directions, before a Class-A or Class-B history sheet is opened, the person concerned must get one opportunity to submit objections, which must be placed before a senior police official who will decide after considering the response. The state must also provide for an annual review of history sheets.

The directions apply to history sheets across Uttar Pradesh.