The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit on Thursday refused to rehear Rep. LaMonica McIver's bid to throw out the federal criminal case against her, leaving the New Jersey Democrat to face trial over a confrontation with federal officers at an immigration detention centre in Newark last year.
Source: Bloomberg Law
In a one-paragraph order dated November 19, 2026, the court denied McIver's petition for rehearing by the panel and by the full court sitting en banc. Only three of the 13 judges who took part in the vote — Judges Restrepo, Krause and Montgomery-Reeves — voted to grant the petition. The order was signed by Circuit Judge Cindy K. Chung. Judge Emil Bove, a former senior Justice Department official, did not take part in the vote.
The August ruling that started this fight
McIver had asked the full court to reconsider a divided ruling handed down on August 26, when a three-judge panel ruled 2–1 that the Constitution's Speech or Debate Clause does not shield her from two of the three counts she faces. Judges Chung and Stephanos Bibas formed the majority; Judge Thomas L. Ambro dissented.
The panel held that prosecuting the first two counts would not require McIver to answer for any legislative act, because the alleged conduct — physically confronting federal officers — was, in the majority's words, 'unambiguously non-legislative'. A third count was sent back to the trial court for further consideration, and the panel declined to review McIver's claims of selective and vindictive prosecution, saying it lacked jurisdiction over them at that stage.
The May 2025 confrontation at Delaney Hall
The charges grow out of an unannounced oversight visit McIver made with two fellow House members to Delaney Hall, a federal immigration detention facility in Newark, on May 9, 2025. Federal officers moved to arrest Newark Mayor Ras Baraka after he entered a fenced part of the property, and a scuffle broke out. Baraka's charges were dropped within days. McIver was indicted the same day.
The three charges — and what prosecutors allege
McIver faces three federal counts of assaulting, impeding and interfering with federal officers. She has pleaded not guilty. According to the court's account of the indictment, prosecutors allege that she slammed her forearm into one officer as officers tried to arrest Mayor Baraka, and used both forearms to strike another officer as she re-entered a secured area. If convicted on all counts, she faces up to 17 years in prison.
“The petition for rehearing by the panel and the Court en banc, is denied.” — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, November 19, 2026
Why Delaney Hall sits at the centre of the case
Delaney Hall is a 1,196-bed facility run by the private prison company GEO Group, and the largest immigration detention centre on the U.S. East Coast. It reopened in May 2025, and three detainees have died in federal custody there since then, prompting a civil rights investigation by New Jersey's attorney general. On November 17, the state sued the Department of Homeland Security, accusing it of stonewalling subpoenas for records about medical care, use of force and conditions inside the facility.
New Jersey sued the Department of Homeland Security on November 17 over the same facility, saying federal officials have ignored subpoenas about conditions at Delaney Hall. Read the earlier story
What McIver and her supporters say
McIver says the prosecution is politically motivated and has warned that it would chill congressional oversight of immigration enforcement. The ACLU of New Jersey, the National Women's Law Center and the NAACP Legal Defense Fund backed her rehearing bid, arguing that the charges are retaliation for oversight work. In his August dissent, Judge Ambro wrote that the executive branch cannot use its prosecutorial power to retaliate against legislators it disfavours.
What happens next
The case now returns to U.S. District Judge Jamel K. Semper in New Jersey, who must apply the appeals court's instructions to the third count. McIver faces arraignment on the remaining counts in the coming weeks, and no trial date has been set. Her legal team has signalled it will ask the U.S. Supreme Court to review the immunity question.
The case is being watched closely in New Jersey, home to one of the largest South Asian and Punjabi communities in the United States, where immigration detention and oversight of federal enforcement are live concerns for many families. A day before the ruling, McIver clashed with Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin at a House hearing over conditions at Delaney Hall and deaths in immigration custody.
What is solid
- The Third Circuit denied McIver's rehearing petition on November 19, 2026.
- Three of the 13 participating judges voted to grant rehearing.
- A divided panel ruled 2–1 in August that immunity does not cover Counts One and Two.
What is only claimed
- McIver says the prosecution is politically motivated.
- The government says the charges concern alleged physical interference with officers, not the oversight visit itself.
