Houston City Attorney Arturo Michel has blocked a move by three City Council members to turn Mayor John Whitmire's order limiting Houston police cooperation with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) into permanent city law, ruling the proposal unlawful under Texas state law.
Source: ABC13 Houston (KTRK)
"The way the ordinance is written, it's unlawful," Michel told reporters on Wednesday morning, November 18. Council Members Edward Pollard, Alejandra Salinas and Tiffany Thomas had proposed codifying Executive Order 1-74, which Whitmire signed on November 6, into a city ordinance.
Source: ABC13 Houston (KTRK)
Why the city attorney said no
Michel said his review found the proposed ordinance in violation of Texas Senate Bill 4, the 2017 law that bars local governments from adopting policies that prohibit or materially limit cooperation with federal immigration enforcement. The Houston Chronicle's November 18 report added a second concern: the ordinance would intrude on the mayor's administrative authority.
"I have to pass on the legality of an ordinance, and I can't ignore the fact that this violates (SB4)," Michel said. "I'm not asked to pass on the legality of (executive orders)." The distinction matters: an executive order is the mayor's own directive and is not subject to the city attorney's legal review, while an ordinance must pass that review before it can go to a vote.
Source: ABC13 Houston (KTRK)
What Whitmire's order does
Under Executive Order 1-74, signed on November 6 — three days after the November 3 statewide election — Houston police officers may contact ICE about a person only when that person has an active criminal warrant or has been arrested for a new criminal offence that could result in jail time, and when a federal database check returns a positive hit for an ICE administrative warrant.
Source: ABC13 Houston (KTRK)
A dispute that began in April
The fight goes back to April, when the City Council adopted an ordinance ending the practice of officers waiting 30 minutes for ICE agents to arrive at traffic stops. Governor Greg Abbott threatened to pull state public-safety grants from the city, the council amended the ordinance, and police were told to contact ICE about anyone with an administrative warrant and wait a "reasonable" time for agents to arrive.
Whitmire himself opposed the effort to codify his order, arguing it could run afoul of state law. The three council members used Proposition A, the 2023 voter-approved measure that lets any three council members place an item on the council agenda.
Paxton's lawsuit is still pending
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton has separately asked a Fort Bend County district court to block the executive order itself, filing a motion on November 13 in a lawsuit first brought in April. The state argues the order violates Senate Bill 4. The motion is not a ruling, and the court has not yet decided the renewed challenge.
Source: Houston Public Media, via Texas Gazette
Paxton leaves office in January. Democrat Nathan Johnson won the November 3 race for attorney general. Michel told Houston Public Media it will be difficult for Paxton to obtain a court ruling before the new administration takes over, which he said has indicated it will not pursue Senate Bill 4 enforcement of this nature.
Source: Houston Public Media, via Texas Gazette
What it means for Houstonians
Because the proposal cannot proceed to a vote, the limits on police contact with ICE remain in place only as a mayoral executive order — which a future mayor could reverse with a stroke of a pen — rather than as city law. Whitmire has said the change will "reduce fear and anxiety" among residents and added, "elections matter." The order does not stop ICE from making its own arrests in Houston, and Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin has denounced the limits as a dereliction of duty.
What happens next
The Fort Bend County court has yet to rule on Paxton's motion. The council proposal stays stalled unless its sponsors rework it to satisfy the city attorney, and the incoming attorney general takes office in January. For now, Houston police policy is exactly what Whitmire's order says it is.
Houston's limits on police contact with ICE survive — but only as a mayoral order, not as law. The city attorney's ruling blocks the council from locking them in, and the state's court challenge is still to be decided.
