The Supreme Court on Wednesday, November 18, sought responses from the Centre, the Delhi government and the Delhi Police Commissioner, along with four political and student organisations, on a petition by Delhi traders' associations challenging the designation of Ramlila Maidan as an authorised protest site.

Source: PTI via Daily World

A bench headed by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and comprising Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana issued notices to the Indian National Congress, CJP, the All India Students Association (AISA) and the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP).

Source: Verdictum

The petition was filed by the Delhi Kirana Committee and the Delhi Iron and Hardware Merchants' Association of Chawri Bazar. The traders have challenged the Delhi Police order dated October 11 that designated Ramlila Maidan, Burari Ground and CBD Ground in east Delhi as protest venues, while removing Jantar Mantar from that list.

The petitioners argue that demonstrations at Ramlila Maidan affect commercial activity, disrupt traffic and create difficulties for people living and working in the surrounding neighbourhoods. They have put the possible loss at over Rs 200 to Rs 250 crore a day during the peak trading period — an estimate presented by the petitioners, not a finding by the court.

No blanket ban sought, say traders

The traders have clarified that they are not seeking a blanket ban on peaceful protests. They want the October 11 police order quashed and a structured framework for where and how demonstrations are held in the national capital.

Chief Justice Kant observed that no protest site can be occupied for all times, but that every person has the right to protest. He said a designated time must be fixed for a designated period, and that any order granting or refusing permission to protest must disclose its reasons.

The bench said it will hear the traders' plea alongside other petitions concerning restrictions on demonstrations and the right to protest on November 27.

The notices follow changes to the list of respondents in the traders' petition. On November 3, the bench had asked the petitioners to include the organisations responsible for the demonstrations as respondents, so that the affected parties could be heard before any order was passed. The Congress was added because it had organised a rally at Ramlila Maidan on November 1.

Senior advocate Mukul Rohatgi appeared for the traders' bodies. The court has not decided whether Ramlila Maidan should be removed from the list of approved demonstration venues.

The challenge also follows a November 1 opposition rally at Ramlila Maidan, which brought demonstrators to the area during the festive trading period.