A Carroll County jury began deliberating on Wednesday afternoon in the trial of former sheriff's deputy Matthew Herpstreith, who is charged in the death of 18-year-old Jackson Kradle on Illinois Route 78 in July 2024. Jurors left the courtroom to begin deliberations at 3:24 p.m. on Wednesday, November 18, after hearing closing arguments from both sides on the third day of the trial, KWQC reported.
Source: KWQC via Rockford News First, Nov 18 2026
Herpstreith, 45, of Savanna, is accused of striking Kradle on Illinois 78 after attending parties through the night, then power-washing his truck to hide evidence, according to prosecutors. The prosecution alleges reckless driving and a cover-up. The defense argues that an impaired Kradle was lying in the roadway in the middle of the night and that the collision was an unavoidable accident, not a crime. Herpstreith has pleaded not guilty, and the charges are allegations that the jury must now weigh.
The charges before the jury
Jurors are weighing felony reckless homicide, felony reckless conduct, felony obstructing justice, a misdemeanor count of attempted obstruction of justice, and a traffic citation for failure to reduce speed. Trial reporting by KJB Reports lists reckless homicide as a Class 3 felony and reckless conduct and obstruction of justice as Class 4 felonies. Special Prosecutor Charles Colburn formally charged Herpstreith in March 2025.
What happened on the night of July 28, 2024
Kradle, who had recently turned 18, died from blunt trauma to the head after being struck by a vehicle in the early morning hours of July 28, 2024, on Illinois Route 78, about one mile north of downtown Mt. Carroll, according to testimony reported by KWQC. A coroner's jury ruled Kradle's death a homicide after evidence implicated Herpstreith and former dispatcher Amy Hubble, who was riding in Herpstreith's truck that night. Carroll County Coroner Matthew Jones testified that Kradle's blood alcohol level was .192 at the time he was hit; defense counsel Joseph Nack told jurors Kradle was lying in the middle of an unlit rural highway with a 0.25 blood-alcohol level. Both figures were presented to the jury by the respective sides.
According to testimony reported in detail by KJB Reports from day two of the trial, the evening began at a retirement party at the Copper Cow in Mt. Carroll for dispatcher Cindy Sisler — Kradle's aunt — followed by a house party, the Sand Burr bar near Thomson, and the Sippi Side bar in Savanna, which closed at around 2 a.m. Video shown to jurors placed the group inside the Sippi Side at about 12:45 a.m. and showed Hubble buying cigarettes at a Casey's in Savanna at 2:21 a.m. Dispatcher Kayla Russell testified she rode in the back seat as Herpstreith drove, saw three liquid beverages inside the truck, and described Herpstreith's level of intoxication as comparable to her own when he dropped her at her Mt. Carroll home.
Hubble, a former Carroll County dispatcher and a licensed paramedic who was granted immunity last month, testified that within about five minutes of leaving Russell's house, heading northbound on Route 78, she heard Herpstreith say “deer in road” as he swerved into the southbound lane, and that she saw “white and some color” on the highway. Seconds later, she testified, Herpstreith said, “I think that's a body in the road,” turned the truck around and stopped. Hubble said she got out to render aid, felt a faint pulse, and could see a large laceration to the head; asked whether anything could have been done to save his life, she answered, “No.” Forensic pathologist Dr. Mark Peters, who performed the autopsy, testified Kradle was either crawling or lying face down when he was run over by a vehicle moving at a speed of at least 40 miles per hour, and that a faint pulse indicated Kradle may still have been alive when Hubble first assessed him.
Source: KJB Reports, Nov 17 2026
The car wash, the deleted text, and the investigation
Prosecutors pointed to what happened next. Security camera footage from 4:03 a.m. to 4:08 a.m. positively identified Herpstreith washing the undercarriage and bottom half of his truck at the Savanna Car Wash, KJB Reports said. Hubble testified she dropped off at her Savanna home at around 3:55 a.m., went to work a dispatch shift less than two hours later, and sent Herpstreith a text that morning — later deleted — saying, “We need to get on the same page for statements,” which she said reflected worry about getting in trouble with the sheriff for not staying at the scene. Illinois State Police case agent Matthew Kipping testified Herpstreith was cooperative and gave verbal consent to inspect his truck, but was not initially forthcoming about taking the truck to a car wash immediately after leaving the scene. On cross-examination, Kipping said he never received information that Herpstreith was intoxicated, tired or inattentive, and that the state police accident reconstruction unit was not used to investigate Kradle's death.
Closing arguments: recklessness or an unavoidable accident
In closing, Colburn told jurors Herpstreith's guilt was clear, arguing that alcohol consumed across multiple bars and afterparties over a nine-hour period, together with fatigue, impaired his driving on dark roads. “If you use due care, you don't run over people,” Colburn said. Prosecutors argued Herpstreith misled investigators by claiming he swerved around an object in the road, then attempted to wash away biological evidence that state police subsequently recovered. Earlier on Wednesday, the defense called mechanical engineer and accident reconstruction expert Zach Bingen, who testified the state's initial investigation lacked critical roadway measurements and vehicle speed data, and that nighttime conditions, rain and low-beam headlights left an average driver with virtually no reaction time to avoid a low-profile object lying in the roadway. On cross-examination, prosecutors noted that fatigue and alcohol lengthen reaction times, and that poor visibility gives drivers a duty to reduce speed rather than drive the limit.
Defense counsel Joseph Nack countered that prosecutors failed to prove recklessness, intoxication or excessive speed. “There is no doubt that a horrible, horrible tragedy happened … but it was an accident,” Nack said, emphasizing that the first responding officer detected no signs of impairment and never conducted a field sobriety or breath test. Nack argued that if Herpstreith had intended a cover-up, he would never have turned around, called dispatch, or cooperated by handing over his phone and vehicle for inspection. On Tuesday, Judge Peska had denied the defense's motion for a directed verdict, in which Nack argued there was “no evidence of recklessness” and said his client had “three, maybe four drinks over 12 hours”; Colburn responded that there was open alcohol in the vehicle, no evidence of braking, and that going to a car wash immediately showed a “consciousness of guilt.”
Background and why the case matters
Herpstreith served with the Carroll County Sheriff's Office from June 2018 to July 2024 and with the City of Savanna Police Department from August 2017 to January 2024, according to Illinois Law Enforcement Training and Standards Board records cited by KJB Reports. The case has drawn close attention across northwestern Illinois because it tests where a tragic nighttime collision on an unlit rural highway ends and criminal recklessness begins — a question that turns on speed, visibility, fatigue and the duty to slow down when a driver cannot see what is ahead. For anyone driving rural two-lane highways at night — including the truckers and shift workers who cross Carroll County after dark — the verdict will be read as a statement about that duty.
The jury deliberated into Wednesday afternoon with access to photographic and video evidence on request. A verdict had not been announced when this report was filed; the story will be updated when the jury returns. Herpstreith remains presumed innocent unless the jury convicts.
