Douglas Prude of Kalamazoo is suing the City of Kalamazoo and two police officers in federal court, alleging violations of his Fourth and Fourteenth Amendment rights arising from his 2019 arrest — an arrest that led to convictions the Michigan Supreme Court later threw out, ordering judgments of acquittal, WKZO reported on Wednesday, November 18.
Source: WKZO via WTOU, Nov 18 2026
According to WKZO, Prude was arrested in 2019 and charged over fleeing and eluding and resisting or obstructing police, was convicted in February 2020, and served nearly six months in jail in 2022. The Michigan Supreme Court acquitted him in 2024 and reversed his convictions. Prude is now suing the two officers who arrested him and the city, alleging the city failed to educate its officers “regarding the constitutional limits on investigative detentions,” WKZO reported.
What the Michigan Supreme Court decided
In People v. Prude, Docket No. 165664, decided July 5, 2024, the Michigan Supreme Court reversed the Court of Appeals, reversed Prude's convictions and sentences, and remanded the case to the Kalamazoo Circuit Court for entry of judgments of acquittal on both charges. In an opinion by Justice Megan K. Cavanagh, the court held that the facts known to the officers, even viewed together, did not provide objectively reasonable, particularized suspicion that Prude was trespassing — so the detention was unlawful. Because lawful police action was a required element of both offenses, the court held the evidence was insufficient to support the convictions.
Source: Michigan Supreme Court opinion, People v. Prude (2024)
The May 30, 2019 encounter at Fox Ridge Apartments
The Supreme Court opinion records that on May 30, 2019, at around 6:30 p.m., Officers Nicholas Deleeuw and Nathan Belen were patrolling the parking lot of the Fox Ridge Apartments complex in Kalamazoo, on directed patrol in an area known for frequent criminal activity. The officers attempted to detain Prude, who was parked in the lot, to investigate whether he was trespassing. After Officer Belen told Prude he was being detained and was not free to leave, Prude started his car, rolled up his window, and drove away at a high rate of speed, according to the opinion. He was later arrested and charged.
Prude was charged with second-degree fleeing and eluding, MCL 257.602a(4), and assaulting, resisting, or obstructing a police officer, MCL 750.81d(1). Both offenses required the prosecution to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the police acted lawfully. Prude moved for a directed verdict at the close of the prosecution's proofs, arguing there was insufficient evidence that he was lawfully detained; the trial court denied the motion, and a jury convicted him of both charges. Only two witnesses testified at the trial: Officers Deleeuw and Belen.
The road from conviction to acquittal
The Michigan Court of Appeals affirmed the convictions in an unpublished per curiam opinion issued March 23, 2023 (Docket No. 360234). Prude sought leave to appeal, and the Supreme Court took the case. The majority held that even the most cursory warrantless seizure must be justified by an objectively reasonable, particularized suspicion of criminal activity, and concluded that standard was not met on these facts. A dissenting view noted the officers were on directed patrol at the property owner's request in a high-crime area — the position the lower courts had accepted — but the majority's ruling controlled, and the convictions could not stand.
What the new federal lawsuit asks
WKZO reports the new federal lawsuit names the two arresting officers and the City of Kalamazoo, claiming Fourth and Fourteenth Amendment violations and alleging the city failed to train or educate its officers on the constitutional limits of investigative detentions. The WKZO report did not include a response from the city or the officers, and no court ruling has been made on the lawsuit's claims, which remain allegations to be tested in federal court.
Why it matters beyond Kalamazoo
Investigative detentions — brief stops based on reasonable suspicion rather than probable cause — are among the most common encounters between police and the public in Michigan, and the Prude case is now one of the state's leading statements of where that power ends: suspicion must be particularized to the person stopped, not borrowed from the reputation of a neighbourhood or a parking lot. For departments across Michigan, the acquittal — and now a federal civil rights suit seeking accountability for the arrest, the prosecution and the jail time that followed — turns a single 2019 parking-lot stop into a training question for every officer who makes such stops.
The federal case will proceed through the city's and officers' responses and any motions to dismiss before discovery or trial. Prude's criminal case is closed: the Supreme Court ordered judgments of acquittal, which means he stands legally innocent of both charges.
