A Michigan marijuana grower's last realistic path to restoring a $31.8 million jury verdict has closed. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit on Monday, November 17, denied Hello Farms Licensing MI's request to reconsider the court's September decision that erased the verdict against two subsidiaries of cannabis giant Curaleaf Holdings, according to a Law360 report of the order.
Source: The Marijuana Herald / Law360
The denial leaves standing a published precedent with consequences far beyond one farm: in the four states covered by the Sixth Circuit — Michigan, Ohio, Kentucky and Tennessee — a federal court will not enforce a contract whose performance requires conduct that federal law still treats as a crime, even when both businesses are fully licensed under state law.
How the dispute began
In November 2020, Hello Farms agreed to sell its entire 2020 and 2021 marijuana harvests to GR Vending MI, LLC, with CURA MI, LLC guaranteeing the buyer's obligations. Both companies are subsidiaries of Curaleaf Holdings, one of the largest cannabis companies in the world. The deal contemplated a 2020 harvest of 12,000 to 15,000 pounds and included a $2.2 million deposit, refundable under certain conditions — one of which required the marijuana to pass local and state recreational cannabis testing requirements.
Source: Newman Law analysis of the Sixth Circuit opinion
Hello Farms grew about 16,300 pounds in 2020, and all of it passed testing. GR Vending paid the deposit and accepted a first shipment of roughly 2,000 pounds. Then wholesale prices fell sharply. By January 2021 the buyer refused further deliveries, and Hello Farms resold the rest of the 2020 harvest — and its larger 2021 harvest — to a third party at lower prices. It sued for lost profits in Michigan state court in February 2021; the case was moved to federal court, a jury awarded Hello Farms $31.8 million, and with prejudgment interest the judgment grew to about $37.2 million.
What the appeals court decided in September
On September 10, 2026, a three-judge panel reversed. Its holding, in the court's own summary, is that “despite the legalization of marijuana in Michigan, federal courts cannot enforce agreements to commit federal crimes.” The judges reasoned that nothing in the contract limited the sale to the medical market, the agreement expressly required recreational testing, and the buyer held both medical and recreational licences — so, on the face of the contract, the parties had promised to commit felonies under the federal Controlled Substances Act.
Source: Sixth Circuit opinion, via Justia
The court went further. Even if the contract had been limited to medical marijuana, it held, the result would be the same: the Rohrabacher-Farr provision in federal spending law, which since 2014 has barred the Justice Department from spending money to block state medical-marijuana programmes, limits prosecutions but does not legalise the conduct. Nor did the April 2026 federal rule moving some state-licensed medical marijuana to Schedule III save the deal — the court said the change was not retroactive to a 2020 contract and would still require registration with the Drug Enforcement Administration.
The panel acknowledged the optics directly: “Hello Farms may understandably view this outcome as a windfall for Defendants. But our task isn't to weigh the equities as we might perceive them. At day's end, we aren't free to enforce agreements to commit crimes.”
Why businesses across four states are watching
Hello Farms petitioned on October 8 for rehearing by the full court, arguing that letting marijuana businesses escape contracts by invoking federal prohibition could create widespread instability in regulated markets. The National Organization for the Reform of Marijuana Laws (NORML) filed a brief supporting reconsideration. Monday's denial rejects that argument without a further published opinion, and the September ruling remains binding precedent on federal courts in Michigan, Ohio, Kentucky and Tennessee. It does not bind Michigan's own state courts, which have not ruled on the same question.
What happens next
Hello Farms can still ask the U.S. Supreme Court to review the case, though the justices accept only a small fraction of petitions and are not required to take it. For now, lawyers who advise Michigan's licensed cannabis industry say the practical lessons are blunt: a state licence is not federal permission, enforceability is judged when a contract is signed, and growers who cannot rely on a court to enforce a supply deal have to protect themselves up front — through deposits, payment timing and security for payment — rather than through a lawsuit afterwards.
