A federal court in New York has formally asked three district courts in Delhi to help serve summons on National Security Adviser Ajit Doval and former Research and Analysis Wing (RAW) chief Samant Goel in the civil lawsuit filed by Sikh separatist Gurpatwant Singh Pannun, Bar and Bench reported on Thursday.

Source: Bar and Bench

In an order dated November 13, US District Judge Katherine Polk Failla of the Southern District of New York directed the court's clerk to send the summonses and accompanying judicial documents by international mail or courier to the receiving courts in Delhi, The Hindu reported.

The order identifies the Patiala House District Court for the documents concerning Doval, and the Dwarka and Tis Hazari district courts for the documents concerning Goel. The US court asked the Delhi courts to accept the summons and other judicial records and cause them to be delivered to the two men, and to send back a written record of the proceedings.

What the order is — and what it is not

The order concerns only the method of delivering legal papers. It is not a finding on the merits of the case, and it does not establish that either official has been served, or that service will be recognised under the applicable law. There has been no finding of liability against either official in the civil proceedings.

The request is made under Article 19 of the Hague Service Convention and Section 29(c) of India's Code of Civil Procedure, which allow foreign judicial process to be transmitted to Indian courts. The US court noted that the standard procedure through India's central authority under the Hague Convention had been attempted but rejected, and that three attempts to serve Doval personally during official visits to the United States were blocked by security personnel.

The earlier step: the November 9 ruling

This is a follow-up to the same court's November 9 ruling, reported by Awaaz Punjab at the time, in which Judge Failla authorised Pannun to attempt service on Doval and Goel through the Delhi courts. That ruling required Pannun to submit a proposed package of documents — including the summons, supporting legal provisions, evidence of the rejected service requests and a formal request for assistance — by November 30.

The November 13 order is the next procedural step: the court has now identified the receiving courts and specified mail or courier as the means of transmission. Whether the papers have reached the defendants, or whether the Delhi courts have acted on the request, has not been established.

The case behind the summons

Pannun, general counsel of the banned organisation Sikhs for Justice, filed the civil suit in September 2024, alleging a conspiracy to assassinate him in New York. The suit names the Government of India, Doval, Goel, Vikram Yadav, Nikhil Gupta and several unnamed defendants. These are civil allegations contested by New Delhi, not findings made by the court.

The Ministry of External Affairs has dismissed the accusations as fabricated and malicious. The civil lawsuit is separate from the federal criminal proceedings in the United States concerning an alleged murder-for-hire plot targeting Pannun.

Service is not a verdict

A summons is a notice to appear, not a finding of guilt. This order moves papers between courts; it decides nothing about the assassination-plot allegations at the heart of the suit.