MODESTO, California — Two Modesto City Council members have asked city officials to draft a policy that would keep federal immigration agents from using city-owned property for enforcement, and elected leaders across Stanislaus County have signed a joint call for all nine of the county's cities to adopt the same kind of rules. The move, launched on Wednesday, November 18, follows the detention of a pregnant U.S. citizen by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents outside the county jail in Modesto three days earlier — an arrest, caught on video, that has drawn national attention.

Source: The Modesto Focus

Earlier in this story

On Sunday, November 15, ICE agents detained Lizbeth Vargas Andrade, a 23-year-old Ceres resident who is 12 weeks pregnant, outside the Stanislaus County jail in Modesto. Video recorded by her husband showed her being taken to the ground and handcuffed. She was released without charges after about five hours in custody. Read the original report

What the letter asks for

Council members Chris Ricci and Eric Alvarez sent a letter on Wednesday asking Modesto officials to model a new policy on the one Fresno adopted a week earlier, which restricts 'the voluntary use of City-owned or City-controlled property for federal civil immigration enforcement activities.' Under the draft they propose, city-controlled property would not knowingly be authorised or voluntarily made available for staging civil immigration enforcement operations. It could also not be used for processing or temporary detention for civil immigration purposes, for surveillance primarily related to civil immigration enforcement, or as an operational or logistical base for such activities, the letter states.

A broader joint statement, spearheaded by Riverbank Mayor Rachel Hernandez and Councilman Ricci, calls on the city councils in all nine of the county's cities — and on school boards and Stanislaus County office holders — to 'adopt Response to Immigration Enforcement policies that keep public property a safe and welcoming place for all residents.' The list of signatories was still growing when the statement was released, and includes Stanislaus County Supervisor Channce Condit, Patterson Mayor-elect Gaby Hernandez, and Stanislaus Union School District trustees John Casselberry and Gricelda Garcia. The statement says the county and its nine cities should adopt their own rules, and that the sheriff should uphold them.

What the council members say

"The fear in our communities is real" and "affects not just undocumented individuals, but the entire community," the joint statement says. Ricci called the stepped-up ICE activity "a foolish errand that is really just a political stunt by the federal government." The statement adds that while local governments cannot control federal activity, "we do decide how our own property, staff, and resources are used."

The arrest that set it off

The drive was spurred by the arrest of Lizbeth Vargas Andrade, a 23-year-old mother of two from Ceres who is 12 weeks pregnant and a U.S. citizen. Around noon on Sunday, November 15, she was in the parking lot of the Stanislaus County Public Safety Center, watching ICE vehicles as part of a volunteer network that alerts residents to agents' movements. Her husband, Adolfo Talavera Alvarado, recorded video showing agents taking her to the ground on her stomach and handcuffing her as he shouted that she was pregnant. Her attorney, Patrick Kolasinski, says an agent also pepper-sprayed her. Agents drove her about 50 minutes to the ICE Enforcement and Removal Operations office in Stockton, held her for about five hours, and released her without any criminal charge at about 8 p.m. She was examined at a hospital, and doctors determined the baby was unharmed. She has diabetes, and her attorney says she was denied access to her lawyer and family for hours.

ICE has given a different account. In a statement on Tuesday, an ICE spokesperson told ABC News that during the incident Vargas Andrade 'actively interfered with, obstructed, and attempted to prevent the arrest — a federal crime.' ICE said the encounter took place during the arrest of a man it described as a Mexican national with multiple DUI charges, and accused Vargas Andrade of assaulting one of its agents — a claim she denies. Kolasinski says multiple videos contradict the assault claim and has called for a thorough and transparent examination of the detention, the force used against her, and her treatment in custody. The Stanislaus County Sheriff's Office has said its deputies had no role in the arrest.

Fresno wrote the template

Modesto is following a path Fresno took first. On Thursday, November 12, the Fresno City Council voted 6-1 to bar city departments and officials from voluntarily letting parks, parking lots, libraries, civic centres and other city-owned sites be used to stage civil immigration enforcement. The resolution, sponsored by Councilmembers Annalisa Perea and Nelson Esparza, passed on the consent calendar. Councilmember Nick Richardson said that without a real implementation plan the measure was 'just words on a page.' No implementation plan exists yet; the city manager and city attorney have been asked to write administrative procedures, with no deadline set. The Department of Homeland Security answered within a day: a spokesperson, Jason B. Sweeney, said ICE 'does NOT need to receive permission from local authorities' to do its job, citing the Constitution's Supremacy Clause.

Fresno was itself following a state law, AB 1807, which takes effect in January and bans immigration enforcement staging on state-owned property. Fremont, Santa Rosa and Alameda County have passed similar measures, and other California cities and counties are considering them. The push comes as the Valley Watch Network, which tracks suspected immigration enforcement across the Central Valley, says its monthly reports jumped from about 300 to 500 a month to between 2,600 and 3,000, and its hotline calls rose from nearly 500 in September to more than 3,000 in October. More than 200 people have been detained by ICE in the Central Valley since early October, according to Fresnoland. In April, ICE officers shot a man in a car on a freeway ramp in Patterson, and on Friday, agents took a Riverbank man away in handcuffs, leaving his family without its breadwinner, Riverbank's mayor said.

6–1Fresno City Council vote to bar ICE staging on city property
9cities in Stanislaus County asked to adopt their own rules
2,600–3,000Valley Watch Network reports a month, up from 300–500

What happens next

The letter only asks Modesto officials to draft a policy; no council vote has been scheduled and no date has been set for a draft to come back. The joint statement asks the county's nine cities, its school boards and the county itself to adopt their own versions, and asks the sheriff to uphold them. Modesto City Schools already has a 'Response to Immigration Enforcement' policy that the statement holds up as a model: it bars immigration agents from non-public areas of public property, vehicles or programmes without a judicial warrant, subpoena or court order; bars collecting or sharing residents' immigration information unless the law requires it; and requires timely reporting of every ICE request for access or records. A community town hall on immigration enforcement was scheduled for Wednesday evening in south Modesto, and Vargas Andrade's family is exploring a civil lawsuit over her detention. Awaaz Punjab will report the draft policy when it is published and the council vote when it is scheduled.

For the Central Valley's large Punjabi community — in Modesto, Ceres, Turlock and Stockton, where many families work in farming, food processing, warehouses and trucking — the debate is not abstract. The joint statement says the fear created by stepped-up enforcement 'affects not just undocumented individuals, but the entire community,' and community monitoring networks that include Punjabi residents have been tracking agents' movements across the county for weeks. What the councils decide will shape whether city parks, parking lots and civic buildings remain places where those families feel safe to gather — or staging grounds for the next enforcement operation.

Awaaz Punjab reported on the community town hall and ICE's first account of the pregnant citizen's detention earlier this week. Read our earlier report