NEW YORK — New York City has ordered the controlled demolition of the building standing next to the Brooklyn site where a three-storey apartment block collapsed last week, killing eight people. The Department of Buildings said on November 18 that 1323 Flatbush Avenue is too unstable for workers to safely shore up, and issued an Immediate Emergency Declaration for its demolition, with a fenced collapse zone established around the building.
The three-storey building at 1323 Flatbush Avenue was heavily damaged when the neighbouring 1321 Flatbush Avenue fell into an excavation at 2625 Bedford Avenue on November 11, killing eight people and injuring 18. The department said 1323 has continued to deteriorate while its interior has been exposed to the elements, and forensic engineers determined that workers could not safely enter it to perform the heavy-duty shoring needed to stabilise it.
"Given the dangerous condition of the building and the imperative to make sure no one else gets hurt, ordering for the controlled safe demolition of the building is the only available option," Buildings Commissioner Ahmed Tigani said in a statement. Before demolition begins, registered contractors will install shoring inside the neighbouring 1325 Flatbush Avenue, work the department said is expected to begin this week. Vacate orders at 1325 and 1327 Flatbush Avenue remain in effect.
City contractors are also replacing soil removed from the north side of the excavation to fill the hole along the property line, work ordered in the interest of public safety that was ongoing on November 18. The department's stop-work order remains in effect at 2625 Bedford Avenue, with only work needed to keep the site safe or assist the investigation allowed to proceed.
The collapse — and what the records show
The collapse itself happened at about 4 p.m. on Wednesday, November 11, when the 1930s mixed-use building at 1321 Flatbush Avenue — apartments above a store, fully occupied — fell into the excavation pit next door while crews were digging the foundation for a new building. The first 911 call came in at 4:01 p.m. Eight people died — six adults, two of them construction workers, and two children — and 18 were injured. Six died at the scene and two more in hospital. The Fire Department ended its search after about 24 hours. The cause has not yet been determined.
City records show the construction site next door had already drawn enforcement action months before the collapse. The Buildings Department issued a stop-work order on March 20, during demolition, after inspectors found inadequate overhead protection for neighbouring properties. When inspectors returned on April 23, they found demolition had resumed, and issued another violation. The company admitted the violation and paid a $10,000 penalty, and the order was lifted on May 8 after the conditions were corrected. After the collapse, the department issued a new stop-work order citing "unsafe construction operations."
An analysis of approved engineering plans and related records by Engineering News-Record found gaps in what the public record can show about the excavation. A March 5 preconstruction survey said detailed information about 1321 Flatbush Avenue's foundation type and other structural features had not been provided. The department directed engineer Jieming Wang of LMW Engineering Group to provide materials and elevations for adjoining foundations on the support-of-excavation drawings; Wang responded on March 12 that the information had been added, but the available records do not identify what investigation or information was used to establish those foundation conditions.
Whether 1321 Flatbush Avenue was actually underpinned remains unclear, as do the depth of the excavation along the property line and which portions of the approved support-of-excavation system had been installed when the building fell. The approved plans also required baseline readings and continued monitoring of neighbouring-building movement, existing cracks and vibration as excavation progressed, with thresholds requiring notification or a halt to work — but that monitoring data is not among the publicly available records reviewed, and the special-inspection reports for excavation sheeting, shoring and bracing have not been released.
Lawsuit alleges cracks were reported weeks earlier
A tenant displaced by the collapse has now sued the landlord and the developers next door, alleging he reported cracks weeks before the building fell. Dengane Omari Jack, a Brooklyn musician who lived at 1321 Flatbush Avenue, filed the complaint in Brooklyn Supreme Court late on Monday, November 16, naming landlord Olufemi Falade, who owns the property through Isolag Realty Corp., and the limited liability companies tied to developers Robert Fischman and Judy Swimer, which own the construction lot at 2625 Bedford Avenue.
Building records reviewed by Gothamist show that a preconstruction survey had already judged the side wall of 1321 Flatbush Avenue, the one facing the excavation, to be in poor shape. Excavation plans drafted by Wang called for steel bracing beams, known as rakers, along the entire perimeter of the lot — with one exception: the stretch where the building collapsed. No one has been charged with wrongdoing, and the cause of the collapse has not been determined.
The building that fell also carried a long enforcement record of a different kind. The city's housing records list 98 open Housing Preservation and Development violations at 1321 Flatbush Avenue, including 21 Class C violations — the category the agency classifies as immediately hazardous. Recent violations included exposed electrical wiring, roof leaks and inadequate water supply for the sprinkler or standpipe system. None of the recent violations reviewed identified foundation failure or structural instability, and the property also carried $170,000 in unpaid Buildings Department penalties, none of them involving the building's structural condition.
A sweep reaching across the city
The city's broader inspection sweep following the collapse has reached other projects involving Wang and special inspector MD Ariful Islam. Gothamist reported on November 17 that the department had inspected at least 24 jobsites in four boroughs tied to the two engineers and issued full or partial stop-work orders at at least five. The agency's wider enforcement sweep of more than 160 construction sites associated with the project team remains under way, and the department is preparing an independent forensic engineering review of the collapse, with debris removal paused in the meantime.
Brooklyn District Attorney Eric Gonzalez said his office is working with the Buildings Department and the police "to determine whether any criminal conduct contributed to this tragedy." Mayor Zohran Mamdani has pledged an investigation into the collapse, and at least eight households from 1321 and 1323 Flatbush Avenue have been displaced.
Dervie Mapp, who lives beside the construction site, told the Associated Press she heard loud popping sounds before looking from her kitchen window and watching the building fall into the excavation. "I saw the whole thing come down," she said.
Next steps: shoring work inside 1325 Flatbush Avenue, then the controlled demolition of 1323 Flatbush Avenue under the emergency declaration; the independent forensic engineering review; and the District Attorney's investigation into whether criminal conduct contributed to the collapse. Vacate orders at 1325 and 1327 Flatbush Avenue remain in effect.
Sources: Engineering News-Record; Gothamist, via Brooklyn Courier; Associated Press.
Source: Engineering News-Record
