Three non-citizens living in Pennsylvania — two of them in the United States illegally — have pleaded guilty in federal court to voting in American elections they were not eligible to take part in, the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania announced on Wednesday. U.S. Attorney David Metcalf said Hacina Saadi, Widarto and Dilea Ochoa-Perez each admitted voting as an alien, a federal offence that carries prison time and fines, in cases investigated by Homeland Security Investigations.
Source: U.S. Department of Justice, Eastern District of Pennsylvania
Saadi, 48, who prosecutors say is a citizen of France residing illegally in Philadelphia, entered her guilty plea on Wednesday before U.S. Magistrate Judge José R. Arteaga to one count of voting as an alien. According to court filings and statements made in court, Saadi knew she was not a United States citizen and voted anyway in the 2024 election. She had been charged by information in October.
Widarto, 56, also of Philadelphia, pleaded guilty on November 12 before U.S. Magistrate Judge Katayoun M. Copeland to one count of voting as an alien. Widarto is a citizen of Indonesia and a lawful permanent resident of the United States — a green-card holder — and admitted illegally voting in the 2024 general election. Prosecutors stressed that lawful permanent residence does not include the right to vote in federal or Pennsylvania elections; only U.S. citizens may vote.
Ochoa-Perez, 44, who prosecutors say is a citizen of Mexico residing illegally in Coatesville, in Chester County, pleaded guilty on November 10 before Judge Copeland to two counts of voting as an alien. She admitted voting in Chester County in both the November 2022 and November 2024 general elections, at a time when she was a Mexican citizen and not a U.S. citizen.
The pleas follow the October charges
The guilty pleas are the latest step in cases this desk has followed since the autumn charging rounds: Saadi was one of four Philadelphia non-citizens charged by information in October with voting in the 2024 election, and Widarto was named again in a five-defendant charging announcement on November 3. Ochoa-Perez had been charged by information with two counts covering the 2022 and 2024 elections. By pleading guilty, all three have now admitted the conduct instead of putting the government to a trial.
When the October charges were announced, Metcalf said in a statement reported at the time: “Our democracy belongs to the American people and no one else. We will continue to prosecute every instance of non-citizen voting that we encounter.” The U.S. Attorney's Office has brought a rolling series of such cases across the Philadelphia region this autumn, charging non-citizens from Pakistan, France, Portugal, Indonesia, Mexico and other countries in separate informations and indictments.
Under both federal and state law, only United States citizens may vote in Pennsylvania elections. Lawful permanent residents (green-card holders), visa holders and people without legal status are all barred, and voting anyway is a federal crime even if the ballot was cast by mistake about eligibility — prosecutors in these cases said the defendants knew they were not citizens.
For Pennsylvania's large immigrant communities — including Punjabi families in Philadelphia and its suburbs who are permanent residents working toward naturalization — the cases are a pointed reminder that the right to vote arrives only with the citizenship oath. A non-citizen who registers or votes before naturalizing risks not only a criminal conviction but also severe immigration consequences, including removal. Immigration lawyers routinely advise green-card holders to decline registration offers at motor-vehicle offices and community drives until they have taken the oath.
What happens next
All three defendants are scheduled to be sentenced early next year, the U.S. Attorney's Office said. Saadi and Widarto each face a maximum possible sentence of one year in prison and a monetary fine. Ochoa-Perez, convicted of two counts, faces a maximum possible term of two years in prison and a $200,000 fine. The actual sentences will be set by the court at the sentencing hearings.
The pleas do not end the wider enforcement drive. Other defendants charged in the autumn rounds are still working through the courts in the Eastern District, and prosecutors have said the investigations by Homeland Security Investigations are continuing. Readers will be updated when sentencing dates are set and when the remaining cases reach pleas or trial.
