A South Carolina grand jury has indicted two Horry County men on murder charges in the 2023 road-rage shooting death of Scott Spivey, more than three years after prosecutors first declined to bring the case. Weldon Boyd and Kenneth Williams were indicted on charges of murder and possession of a deadly weapon during the commission of a crime, according to Horry County court documents.

Source: WPDE (ABC 15)

The charges stem from a shooting on Camp Swamp Road on September 9, 2023, in which Boyd — a North Myrtle Beach businessman — shot Spivey, 33, of Tabor City, North Carolina. Boyd has maintained from the start that he acted in self-defense. Williams, his close friend, was a passenger in Boyd's vehicle and is charged as a co-defendant.

Source: WPDE (ABC 15)

What happened on Camp Swamp Road

According to case records, the confrontation began as an alleged road-rage encounter along S.C. 9 / Highway 9 and ended on Camp Swamp Road near Longs, where Spivey was shot and killed in his truck. Boyd called 911 during the encounter and told dispatchers he would shoot Spivey if he kept waving a gun at him, according to recordings released by county police. Horry County police initially described Spivey as the aggressor in the confrontation.

Source: LUNASHARK Media

The case then stalled. In April 2024, after a seven-month review, the South Carolina Attorney General's Office declined to prosecute Boyd or Williams, citing insufficient evidence, and the criminal case was closed. No criminal charges were filed against either man — even as Spivey's family pressed on with a wrongful-death lawsuit filed in June 2024.

Source: LUNASHARK Media

A civil case that kept the questions alive

The family's wrongful-death suit, brought by Spivey's sister Jennifer Spivey Foley, forced the evidence into open court. In February 2026, after a four-day Stand Your Ground hearing, Horry County Circuit Court Judge Eugene C. Griffith Jr. denied both men immunity from civil liability under South Carolina's self-defense law — ruling on February 21 for Boyd and March 6 for Williams. The judge found Williams had failed to prove by a preponderance of the evidence that he was entitled to immunity. The ruling did not decide criminal guilt, but it meant the family could pursue the civil case in court.

Source: LUNASHARK Media

Behind the scenes, a separate investigation was widening. In February 2026, 7th Circuit Solicitor Barry Barnette impaneled a State Grand Jury — originally to examine how Horry County police handled the shooting — and state investigators later searched Boyd's home and his North Myrtle Beach restaurant, Buoys on the Boulevard, as the inquiry widened. By November, the defense itself told a judge the grand jury's scope had expanded to cover Boyd's and Williams' own conduct, and on November 9 the two men asked the court to pause the civil case while the grand jury investigation continued.

Source: Myrtle Beach News

The family's response

Mark Tinsley, the attorney representing Spivey's family, said the indictments were “an important step toward accountability” — but stressed they are not convictions. “They do not bring Scott back, and they cannot undo the pain his family has endured,” he said, adding that the family is grateful to the investigators and prosecutors who kept pursuing the case. “Scott Spivey's life mattered.”

33Age of Scott Spivey when he was killed
Sept. 9, 2023Date of the shooting on Camp Swamp Road
3 years, 2 monthsTime between the shooting and the indictments
2Defendants indicted — Boyd and Williams
April 2024When prosecutors first declined to charge

What happens next

The criminal case now moves forward in Horry County, where Boyd and Williams will face arraignment and the court will set bond and trial dates. The charges are accusations, not findings of guilt, and both men are presumed innocent until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. The civil wrongful-death case, Foley v. Boyd and Williams, remains pending in Horry County, and the State Grand Jury's wider inquiry into the original police investigation has not been formally closed.

Source: WPDE (ABC 15)

For Horry County, the indictments close one chapter of a case that has shadowed the community for three years — and open another. The shooting raised questions that went beyond one roadside confrontation: how self-defense claims are tested, how police describe a shooting in its first hours, and what it takes for a family to keep a case alive after prosecutors walk away. Those questions will now be answered in a criminal courtroom.