KABUL, Nov 18 — Afghan Interior Minister Sirajuddin Haqqani has said many people still disagree with the policies of the Taliban's supreme leader, Hibatullah Akhundzada, in remarks at a gathering at a Kabul university on Monday, November 16, that have drawn wide attention as a rare public sign of division inside the movement's leadership.

Source: CGN Today

Haqqani said that in an Islamic system the individual is not what matters — the system itself is what is important. Insisting on personal views when addressing problems within the government, he warned, would make the whole system dependent on a single individual.

The interior minister told those present that there was no need to praise or glorify Akhundzada, and urged officials instead to fulfil their responsibilities and listen to people's problems.

He said a system founded on the principles and values of Sharia would achieve stability and progress, while systems that contradicted Sharia would not endure — and he stressed that public support was essential for the system's survival, acknowledging that many people had yet to recognise its significance and needed to be shown it was in their own best interests.

A loyalty gathering that exposed a disagreement

The Kabul University gathering was organised as a show of loyalty to Akhundzada, with students told to stay away from November 15 to 19 while clerics and officials met on the campus, South Asia Times reported. Haqqani's remarks there openly acknowledged rising public anger and disagreement with the leadership's harsh decrees, the report said.

Source: South Asia Times

Khyber Chronicles, reporting the same speech, said Haqqani cautioned that allowing personal opinions to become the final basis for settling government affairs would leave the governing structure dependent on one man, and noted that Akhundzada — who has stayed out of public view since the 2021 takeover — exercises supreme authority over major political and policy decisions in a highly centralised structure.

Source: Khyber Chronicles

Haqqani described the current responsibilities of governing as more difficult than those faced during the 20-year war against the former Afghan government, saying that steering people away from acts considered forbidden under Islam and preventing hostility among them was no easy task.

Other senior figures have defended the leadership in the same period. Taliban Justice Minister Abdul Hakim Sharaie, speaking on Monday, defended Akhundzada's authority in ideological terms and acknowledged that even some Taliban members had questioned provisions of the Law on the Promotion of Virtue and Prevention of Vice, according to Kabul Times reporting — a further sign that the internal debate is being conducted in public.

Why it matters

Haqqani leads the powerful Haqqani network inside the Taliban and is one of the few senior figures able to voice disagreement publicly. His Kabul remarks do not announce any policy change, but they put the movement's internal argument — centralised rule from Kandahar versus a system that outlasts one leader — on the record, at a time when Pakistan and China are both pressing Kabul on security and cooperation.