A Bakersfield bakery that refused in 2017 to sell a wedding cake to a lesbian couple has settled California's discrimination lawsuit and agreed to serve all customers, the California Civil Rights Department (CRD) announced on Monday, November 16. Under the settlement, Tastries will sell its non-customized products, including cakes, to all customers regardless of sexual orientation, ending a legal fight that lasted nine years and reached the U.S. Supreme Court.

Source: California Civil Rights Department (Nov 16, 2026)

"In California, we don't turn people away because of who they love or where they come from," said CRD Director Kevin Kish. "Whether it's a bakery, restaurant, coffee shop, or grocery store, we are all entitled to full and equal services at businesses in our state. When people like Eileen and Mireya Rodriguez-Del Rio are brave enough to speak out for their rights, it can often help strengthen those protections for everyone. This settlement shows that California is open to business for all."

What the settlement requires

The agreement is more than a promise to serve customers. Tastries must update its sales policy and its staff training, attend civil-rights trainings provided by CRD every year, and post CRD notices about civil-rights protections inside the business, the department said. The bakery must also notify CRD of any discrimination complaints it receives and report to the department every year on its compliance with the settlement.

$12,000Damages and fees Tastries agreed to pay
2017Year the bakery refused the cake sale
2018Year California sued the bakery
9 yearsLength of the legal fight

The $12,000 payment covers damages and fees. The settlement was secured for the state by Associate Chief Counsel Soyeon Oum and Assistant Chief Counsel James Zahradka, and the department said the terms are set out in a proposed consent decree submitted to the court. CRD was represented by the Office of the Attorney General in the appellate proceedings.

How the case began in 2017

In 2017, Eileen and Mireya Rodriguez-Del Rio tried to buy a generic, multi-purpose white cake at Tastries to celebrate their wedding. The bakery refused, because of its policy not to sell cakes for celebrations of same-sex unions, CRD said. The couple filed a complaint with the department, investigators found cause to believe the bakery had violated state civil-rights law, and California sued Tastries in 2018. The business is owned by Catharine Miller through Cathy's Creations, Inc., and the Court of Appeal record describes it as a small Bakersfield bakery employing about 18 people, with wedding cakes a major share of its sales.

Source: California Court of Appeal, Fifth District, opinion in Civil Rights Department v. Cathy's Creations (2025)

The law at the centre of the case is the Unruh Civil Rights Act, California's long-standing statute requiring businesses — bakeries, restaurants, hospitals and retail stores among them — to offer full and equal access to goods and services without discriminating on protected grounds, including sexual orientation. CRD said the settlement once again affirms those protections for businesses operating in the state.

The road through the courts

The case swung back and forth for years. A Kern County trial court ruled in favour of the bakery in late 2022, accepting arguments that included the owner's referral of the couple to another bakery. CRD appealed, and in 2025 the California Court of Appeal ruled in favour of the state, finding the refusal was intentional discrimination. The appellate court also clarified that, unlike the custom website design at issue in the U.S. Supreme Court's 303 Creative case, a predesigned, multipurpose cake does not count as protected speech. The California Supreme Court then denied review of the appeal decision, and the U.S. Supreme Court likewise denied review the same year, leaving the state's win in place.

Only after those doors closed did the bakery settle. Reporting by LGBTQ Nation, citing Bakersfield station KGET, said the agreement was reached on Friday, November 13, and CRD announced it publicly on Monday, November 16. The department directs anyone who believes they have faced discrimination at a California business to its complaint process, which is how the Rodriguez-Del Rio case itself began in 2017.

What changes for customers

The settlement covers Tastries' non-customized products — the predesigned cakes and other goods it sells to the public. Those must now be sold to every customer, regardless of sexual orientation or any other protected characteristic, and the bakery must report back to the state every year on how it is complying.

What happens next: the proposed consent decree goes before the court, and Tastries begins its annual cycle of CRD training and compliance reporting. For California's large Punjabi and South Asian community — including the many families who run bakeries, restaurants and shops of their own across the Central Valley and the state — the case is a clear statement of the rule that governs every business open to the public in California: the same goods, on the same terms, for everyone.